CSAS 09
Paper Abstracts, by first authorÕs first name
(name-
affiliation-session-title-abstract)
Aaron
Stumberg and Crystal Patil, University of Northern Iowa, 3-12
Catchment
Analysis of Hartman Reserve
Hartman
Reserve is a 300-acre nature center and state preserve located in Black Hawk
County, Iowa. An area bordering the Cedar River and rich in wildlife, Hartman
Reserve had never been subjected to professional archaeological scrutiny until
2008 when the University of Northern Iowa conducted test excavations along the
bluff. This effort yielded both historic and prehistoric materials and the
initial analysis of the prehistoric artifacts, including ceramics and lithics,
has begun to provide information to help better understand the Woodland era in
northeastern Iowa, especially the role played by the reserveÕs prehistoric
inhabitants in regional cultural traditions. Through reconstructing the
environment of the Cedar River Valley during the Woodland era we will perform
catchment analysis and evaluate the resources available for utilization.
Discussion will include the significance of such resources and their ability to
attract inhabitants. The primary means of analysis will be performed using GIS
mapping of site 13BH164 as well as the surrounding area and resource zones.
Agnes
Loeffler, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, 2-10
Microscopy
and the quest for diagnostic certainty: disease classification in surgical
pathology
Pathology,
the epistemological core of allopathic (bio-)medicine, is not an overtly social
practice, and thus nearly invisible in medical anthropological literature. In
medical and popular culture, however, it is perceived as the ultimate
authority: the locus at which diagnostic mystery is resolved and certainty established.
I will draw pathology into medical anthropological discourse by analyzing its
role in medicine from a cognitive point of view. I chose this approach because
pathology is centrally concerned with classification (of diseases). In accord
with schema theory, diagnostic names are performative: by summarizing salient
criteria, they become templates for therapeutic action. The relationship of a
named object with the uses to which it is put is well theorized in the
cognitive literature, however, the interpretation of the signs a name
summarizes is usually not reflected upon or problematized. In this paper, I
focus on three problems inherent in the interpretive acts of surgical
pathology: 1) Everything seen under the microscope must be named, but in
practice not everything is classifiable. How do pathologists approach
diagnostic dilemmas? 2) How reproducible is a diagnosis on the same piece of
tissue, i.e. how accurately can pathologists use their classificatory schemes?
3) What criteria other than microscopic appearance are considered in diagnostic
interpretations? With data from the academic literature, interviews with
pathologists, and my readings as a pathologist-anthropologist of diagnostic
reports, I explore interpretive practice in surgical pathology, thereby
engaging it with the discourse on the social creation of clinical
"facts."
Alan R.
Sandstrom and Pamela Effrein Sandstrom, Indiana University-Purdue University
Fort Wayne, 1-2
Commitment
and Ethnographic Research: The Work of Fieldwork among the Huastecan Nahua in
Mexico
Our
ethnographic research in a single Nahua community of 600 people has extended
over more than three decades. One would think that by now we must know
everything about this tiny slice of humanity and yet whole new cultural vistas
open with each return trip. The value of long-term field research depends on
the depth of cultural information sought, and the degree to which the group is
willing to collaborate. Little-noted advantages to the long-term research
commitment is that it allows the ethnographers time to grow intellectually and
thus produce more sophisticated analyses, and it counters the postmodernist
critique that anthropologists are simply after quick and easy data to further
their careers. Long-term researchers devote their lives to the people they
study. One major disadvantage with this research strategy is that it is easy to
lose the creative estrangement that gives cross-cultural ethnography so much of
its power to elucidate sociocultural phenomena.
Alexander
Markovic, University of Illinois at Chicago, 3-13
ÒAuthenticity
for Sale: Musical Performance and Romani Identity in southeastern SerbiaÓ
Since
Ottoman times Romani musicians in the Balkans have cultivated diverse musical
repertoires in order to monopolize entertainment niches among all local ethnic
groups. Since the 1990s, rising local unemployment, transnational migration,
and global Òworld musicÓ markets have impacted Romani musiciansÕ performances
in southeastern Serbia. In this paper I argue that musicians in Vranje
strategically link musical practices and local Romani identity to secure
clientele and augment their earnings in response to changing opportunities and
new potential audiences. In doing so, they attempt to market ÒauthenticÓ Romani
identity and ÒlocalÓ music in order to improve their economic and social
status.
Alice
Kehoe, Univeristy of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, 2-3
ÒWe Have Been Here for 10,000
YearsÓ: Issues Over First NationsÕ
Prehistories
The Montana
Blackfeet tribal website proclaims, ÒWe Have Been Here for 10,000 Years.Ó As an archaeologist, I cannot
endorse this claim, because the archaeological record does not include data
that would identify ethnic or linguistic affiliation older than perhaps 700 years.
I discuss how archaeologists working with Blackfoot nations, including one who
is Blackfoot, deal with the claim.
Alison D.
Goebel, University of Illinois at
Urbana-Champaign, 3-11
ÒMixedÓ
Relationships in the Small City: Race, Gender, and Small City Urbanity
Long a
legal and cultural taboo in the United States, interracial romantic
relationships have become increasingly more visible and unremarkable within the
last forty years. Yet stigmatization and resistance continues. Drawing on more
than 14 months of ethnographic research in one small deindustrializing,
multiracial city- Mansfield, Ohio- I examine the dominant discourses used to
make sense of ÒmixedÓ relationships (the preferred local term). Using research
with participants and observers of mixed relationships, I explore how white
Mansfielders imagine white womanhood in heterosexual relationships and white
racial ÒdarkeningÓ in both straight and gay/lesbian relationships. I argue that
these discourses both contest and reaffirm middle class whiteness and white
masculinity. I contextualize my analysis in MansfieldÕs space and history and
argue that the socio-spatial specificity of small cities produce racial, class,
and gender projects that differ from those found in global cities.
Allan
Meyers, Eckerd College, 3-17
Cultural
Appropriation of Bullfighting in Rural Yucatan, Mexico
One
mechanism by which indigenous cultures in Mesoamerica have persisted is
appropriation, where local groups assert control over foreign customs imposed
by a dominant society. This study explores cultural appropriation in the
bullfighting tradition of rural Yucatan, Mexico. Spaniards imposed the
well-known, if controversial, event in colonial times, and the regionÕs
Maya-language population reinvented it to better suit their worldview. Two
fundamental acts of ancient Maya creation, the setting down of the cosmic
hearth and the raising of the World Tree, are acknowledged at each event.
Likewise, certain key elements of the contest may be linked to a precolumbian
ritual associated with prosperity and social responsibility. Unlike bullfights
in Spain, those of rural Yucatan reflect a much higher social tolerance for
uncertainty and ambiguity. They suggest remarkable cultural tenacity in the
face of modern globalizing forces.
Amber R.
Clifford-Napoleone, University of Central Missouri, 3-2
Crossing
the Disciplinary Line: Anthropology, Cultural Studies, and the Study of
"Jazz"
The paper
ÒCrossing the Disciplinary LineÓ examines and challenges the disciplinary
boundary between anthropology and cultural studies. Historically the relationship
between anthropology and cultural studies has been contentious, and this is
exemplified in the study of Òjazz.Ó While scholars in cultural studies utilize
anthropology, they continue to avoid the appearance of Òusing anthropologyÓ to
study the cultures of jazz. The avoidance of anthropology in cultural studies,
which stems from a widespread misconception that anthropology has remained
static since its origins, gives cultural studies scholars a convenient
scapegoat for the inherently canonical moves in jazz studies. At the same time,
jazz is increasingly appearing in academic anthropology as a topic of study,
but these studies are focused on the ethnomusicology of jazz sounds, improvised
performance, and what anthropologist of jazz Alessandro Duranti calls Òthe
acquisition of jazz aesthetics.Ó AnthropologistsÕ avoidance of new jazz studies
stems from an oversimplified conception of cultural studies, and the belief
that jazz scenes are now essentially dead: in other words, because the
historical peoples and cultures of ÒjazzÓ cannot Òspeak,Ó anthropologists are
reticent to study them. Using the concept of hybridity, autoethnography, and
her own work on jazz cultures in Kansas City, the author will explore this
disciplinary fragmentation and suggest a field of possibilities exists in the
blending of anthropology and cultural studies.
Amy
Kordeck, Indiana University Northwest, 3-3
Material
Culture, Purchasing Power, and Restructuring Tradition
Consumer
capitalism, and in general the act of shopping, is often discredited in
anthropology as a purging of some ideal authentic via Benjaminian critique. The
topic of shopping, however, may be viewed as a radical choice, elevating the
status of the often denigrated, mundane activity. In this sense, shopping is a
commodity much like MaussÕ gift– it is form that implicates every aspect
of social life, such that kinship, time, and political economy are brought
together in a single medium. This paper examines shopping in Gozo through this
and other lenses. Through a descriptive account of GozoÕs 18-20 year old female
shoppers with whom I spent my field season, I use shoppingÕs social
implications to examine the difference of cultural interpretation. The
influences of transnational ideals from a variety of sources are further
analyzed, and their affects on the rational and radical economic choices become
symbolic of greater cultural and social ideals in and of Gozitan space.
Amy
Stringwell, Illinois State University, 1-6
The Effects
of Budget Cuts on Illinois Museums and Historic Sites
In this
paper I examine the effects that recent changes in the Illinois State budget
have had on local museums and historic sites. I examine if these changes are
more due to the current economic downturn, or if these types of closings are
cyclical or political, concerning policies on acquisition, collection and
repatriation of objects and antiquities. I demonstrate this through participant
observation and interviews with professionals at seven sites and museums: the
David Davis Mansion, Dixon Mounds, the McLean Country Historical Museum, the
Field Museum, the Abraham Lincoln Presidential Museum, Dixon Mounds, and
Cahokia Mounds. I focus on what museums are doing to increase patronage, and
discuss what changes in marketing or advertising have taken place. I argue
that, ironically, decreased state funding can also have some important positive
effects, as budget cuts to smaller museums will often cause local community
support to increase. This can sometimes ameliorate the disparities and arbitrary
funding decisions made at the state level.
Andrea
Abrams, Centre College, 3-6
Holy Gender
Politics: Womanist Theology in Theory and Practice
First
Afrikan Church in Atlanta, Georgia is a middle class Afrocentric religious
community in the proces of creating an identity and nurturing a culture that
privileges African ways of knowing and being. This paper concentrates upon the
womanist theological rhetoric of the leadership and its influence on the
consciousness of the membership. The church leadership is in the process of
developing a pedagogy which centers feminist theology as a way to combat the
sexist and patriarchal tendencies found within both Afrocentrism and the
Christian church. The paper investigates how successfully the church is able to
integrate Womanist ideology into an Afrocentric space and reconcile the
long-standing tensions between feminism and black nationalism. As has been
notes by many feminists of color, nationalists and black empowerment movements
have embraced patriarchal ideology and privileged maleness. Accordingly, the
perspectives and needs of Black women have been considered less important and
some organizations have even articulated an antipathy for feminist ideology. So
how does womanism exist within this space and will it be able to flourish? I
argue that it exists because of the highly educated leadership and
congregation, who acclimated to progressive ideologies within academia, are
better able to tolerate it within the church. However, to tolerate is not to
embrace the ideology or engage in feminist infused practices and behaviors.
Therefore, this paper also scrutinizes the extent to which Womanist theological
teachings have influenced male-female dynamics within the lives of church
members.
Andrea
Rissing, Grinnell College, 2-14
Women
Farmers and Feminism: Gender's Impact on Alternative Farming Methods
This paper
explores the relationship that Iowan women farmers perceive between their
gender self-identity and chosen agricultural practices. Drawing on my
ethnographic work on 13 women farmers in Iowa during summer 2008, I investigate
the extent to which a woman attributes her agricultural practices (ie,
conventional or alternative) to her gender, and what factors may influence
this. Informed by Lila Abu-Lughod and Gayatri SpivakÕs approaches, I use a
feminist anthropological theoretical perspective in order to balance my
subjectÕs voices and explanations with my etic analysis. While some women
staunchly say that being a woman has no influence on how they farm, others feel
that traditionally feminine traits, such as nurturing and acting as caretakers,
have positively influenced their practices. Overall, the paper argues that the
personal process of accepting oneÕs gender as a main or partial explanation for
oneÕs farming methods is an irrefutably individual one, and is linked to a
personÕs education, spiritual beliefs, and personal background.
Andrew
Flachs, Oberlin College, 2-4
The
Capabilities Approach: Navigating Cultural Politics in Human Rights Discourse
This paper
explores the percieved incompatibilities between human rights discourse and
traditional values in the Middle East and North Africa. After reviewing
relevant literature and concepts, it posits that this conflict is the result of
social, political, and economic factors within a historical context and
suggests using capabilities approach forwarded by Martha Nussbaum and Amartya
Sen as a tool for better understanding and implementing human rights in the
region. Rather than see culture as an adversary, this approach explains the
potential of culture and religion in resolving ideological conflicts,
especially for ambiguous human rights. This paper presents veiling as an
example of a vaguely defined human right and posits that the capabilities
approach is uniquely equipped to navigate its role in cultural politics.
Angela C.
Ghionea, Purdue University, 1-3
The Role of
Human Prints and Divine Traces in Persuasive Rituals
Whereas an
extensive research has been done on the role of religious relics, the special
topic of body imprints as visible proofs of the invisible world remains highly
neglected. My objective is to investigate the role of prints (such as
footprints, handprints) that were handled by practitioners of magic, medicine
and religions along with the history of humankind. The research argues that
prints were employed in a rational way in order to reinforce the set of beliefs
associated with them. Reciprocally, human body and its traces were used to
persuade divine forces to act on their behalf through occult rituals. The study
shows that for the livings, the solely solid evidence of the existence of these
supernatural characters (gods, fairies, and demons) was their visible traces.
In conclusion, this study brings new contributions by investigating the
relation between the human self-perception and the need for self-persuasion
that God(s) really existed.
Angela
Glaros, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2-2,
Turning the
Song, Turning the Tables: Politics and Musical Performance in Skyros, Greece
This paper
draws on my research on the performance of "traditional" vocal music
on the Greek island of Skyros, in order to understand how Skyrians use musical
performance to enact a politics of community. A small island with approximately
3,000 inhabitants, Skyros enjoys a reputation for ÒtraditionÓ in expressive
arts and music—including the unaccompanied Òtable songsÓ (traghoudia tis
tavlas) that Skyrians perform at celebratory feasts. These songs employ
Byzantine musical modes, intricate melodies and evocative poetry, as well as an
antiphonal call-and-response form in which a secondary singer or group of
singers repeats the refrain (pountos). This practice, which Skyrians call
Òturning the songÓ (yirisma), resonates with other antiphonal vocal forms in
Greece, as well as with widely held cultural values of reciprocity,
hospitality, and commensality. Moreover, such values coalesce around the table,
a space in which Skyrians perform ideals of communal participation in eating,
drinking, talking and singing. As many Skyrians consider their table songs and
older ways of life to be equally Òendangered," I extend the concept of
Òturning the songÓ to the ways in which they frame ÒtraditionalÓ vocal music as
a form of knowledge that links past and present. I compare Clean Monday (Kathara
Dheftera) festivities and saint's day feasts (panegyria) on Skyros to
illustrate how musical performances in these settings enact—or fail to
enact—an intersubjective politics of community that "turns the
tables" on the perceived demise of Skyrian "tradition."
Anna
Musun-Miller, IUPUI Museum Studies, 2-12
Red Speech
Bubble: Comics and Disenfranchised Voices in the Museum
Comic books
have long been a means of entertainment for a large portion of society, but
they are also a vehicle for the perpetuation of stereotypes in a medium that
often goes unexamined. In particular, non-Native artists have a long history of
using Native stereotypes to sell their comic books, but very few artists have
been criticized for doing so. Native American peoples have over the last few
decades taken up the production of comic books, trying to change public
perceptions of what it means to be Native. Museums have very rarely displayed
or critically examined comic books, although many museums are concerned with
stereotypes and Native peoples. By not examining comics as social commentary,
museums are marginalizing not only the customer base which consumes comics but
also the artists which produce comics by making the value judgment that they
are not worth exhibiting.
Ashley Ransburg,
The University of Toledo, 3-15
Role of the
Environment in Shaping Supermarket Competitiveness
This paper
investigates the extent to which cultural and societal factors including class,
stratification, labor-management relations, consumerism, and local
environmental account for differences in efficiency between two Kroger grocery
stores. The study was initiated based on the observations of the author as an
anthropology student and current, three year employee of Kroger. In the study,
two Kroger stores were chosen and compared: one considered to be highly
efficient and profitable and the other less efficient and profitable. Data
collection for the project included in-depth interview with rank-and-file
workers, store, and district managers; employee satisfaction surveys;
observation of department head meetings, cultural council meetings, and other
in store meetings between workers and supervisors. As data analysis is ongoing,
results from the study will be presented. This study is important because it enhances
our understanding of workplace relations from an industrial anthropological
perspective.
Aubrey
Thamann, Purdue University, 3-2
An
Interdisciplinary Ethnographic Study of Funeral Directors in Indiana
In the
West, we have a unique relationship with death—a terrible fear as well as
a deep fascination. This has been reflected in the way we think about and
interact with funeral directors. There is very little academic work centering
on those in the United States who deal with death on a daily basis. An interdisciplinary
ethnographic look at funeral workers does not seem to exist at all. In this
paper, I will discuss several important questions. Death has been called the
ultimate equalizer, but is this true? In a seemingly male-dominated field, men
must cross stereotypical borders and become nurturers. How do they negotiate
these borders? Why is funeral directing a male-dominated field? Why do more
women not become funeral directors? Are there racial or ethnic issues involved
in the funeral trade? Are perceived racial and class divisions more important
to people than religious affiliation in terms of mourning rituals, or are there
multiple factors involved in choosing a funeral home? I also want to discover
how those who work within the space between life and death negotiate this
liminality in terms of identity both as individuals and as part of their
communities. What do the death practices of smaller ethnic, religious, and
class communities in the US tell us about the larger cultural context of a
national identity? By utilizing different disciplinary approaches such as
psychology, history, and anthropology, I hope to create an interdisciplinary
ethnographic study of the American funeral home that will answer these
questions.
Audrey
Ricke, Indiana University, 3-16
Politics
and Performance: Creating Community Bavaria Style of Munich's Oktoberfest
MunichÕs
Oktoberfest preceded the formation of Germany and has endured numerous plagues
and wars. While on the surface Oktoberfest may seem like just one big celebration
of beer, a more in-depth review of the festival reveals how it creates
community while providing a means through which the politically dominant can
assert their power. An analysis of the Oktoberfest parades and beer tents
reveals that the festival serves as a symbol of unity that operates on a
regional level as a way for Bavaria to illustrate its power within the nation
and on a local level for MunichÕs breweries and their landholders to display
and perpetuate their economic power. As an event set apart from daily routine,
it provides a space of liminality wherein the shared performance of Bavarian
identity at the festival creates community (Turner 1969). This very process of
community formation is also one of performing politics through the manner in which
regional identities are represented and consumed.
Azizur R.
Molla, Grand Valley State University, 1-6
Public
Health Risks Associated With Indoor Radon Gas in Rural Pennsylvania
With its
history of coal mining, Tioga County PAÕs radon level indicates a high
geological potential of radon gas. I collaborated with Mansfield University
students to conduct a study of radon gas and peopleÕs knowledge of its health
affects in this rural county of about 1,000 square miles (97% of which is
undeveloped) with a population of about 41,000 (98% white, mostly Republican,
84% rural) in northern PennsylvaniaÕs Allegheny Plateau. With one of the
highest unemployment rates in Pennsylvania, more than 13% of households are
below the poverty line. In this paper, I use the findings of the study to
analyze the relationship between indoor radon levels and socioeconomic status
of the households, the spatial distribution of indoor radon gas, and to assess
the degree of public awareness about the danger of indoor radon gas. I also
explore some socioeconomic variables that influence peopleÕs knowledge about
radon gas and its impact on health. Finally, I deal with the public policy
implications of the findings of this study as an example of collaborative
anthropology which engages significant public issues and problems and discuss
my experiences as a Bangladeshi in this collaboration with students, officials,
and the public of the county.
Barbara
Crass, Universityof Wisconsin- Oshkosh & Manitowoc, 2-3
Swan Point-
14,000 Years of Occupations
Swan Point,
one of a group of multicomponent sites in the Shaw Creek drainage of the Tanana
Valley in central Alaska, is currently the oldest known site in Alaska at about
14,000 calibrated years B.P. Five
culture zones (CZ1a, CZ1b, CZ2, CZ3, and CZ4) are identified at Swan Point,
illustrating changes in people, environment and lifestyle. The earliest occupants (CZ4) are
Eastern Beringians who utilized toolkits similar to those seen in Western
Beringian sites such as Dyuktai Cave.
The latest occupants (CZ1a) are protohistoric and historic hunters,
trappers, and now, archaeologists.
These culture zones will be described, with the most attention focused
on the earliest culture zones, CZ3 and CZ4.
Baron
Pineda, Oberlin College, 3-17
Indigenous
Experience at the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Peoples
Based on
fieldwork at the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues that met for the first
time in 2002, this paper explores the theoretical and methodological issues
that arise when doing ethnographic fieldwork about indigenous participation in
international meetings of this kind. In particular I address the ways in which
ideas about culture, identity and cultural difference are invoked by different
actors at these meetings including indigenous representatives, members of the
Permanent Forum, members of NGOs and representatives of UN agencies.
Bill
Guinee, Westminster College, 2-9
A New
Methodology for Narrative Sequence Analysis
Narrative
sequence analysis examines the order in which information is presented within a
narrative. Earlier attempts have shown how a narrative fits into a presupposed
performative or structural pattern. After briefly reviewing these approaches, I
will report on a new methodology that I am currently developing collaboratively
with Russ Bernard, Selcen Phelps, and Gene Johnsen. This methodology analyzes
and looks for patterns in the order in which observed narrative motifs, in a
given genre, appear in a substantial sample of stories. The fact that the
sequence of personal experience narratives differs from the order of the lived
events being recorded is taken as meaningful. Rather than assuming that this
difference is accounted for by sloppy narrative practice, we consider the
possibility that the speakers are rearranging events strategically to achieve
an effect. As an initial project, we are analyzing several hundred brief
narratives as related in Alcoholics Anonymous discussion meetings.
Bill
Wedenoja, Missouri State University, 1-5
Applying
Anthropology (with the help of students) in a Jamaican Community
Nine years
ago I decided to offer a short-term study tour to Jamaica to provide a
cross-cultural learning experience for anthropology majors. The ÔBluefields
ProjectÕ has evolved considerably since then, with the focus shifting from
students to the community, and from education to service-based research.
Working for the community has led me in many new and unexpected directions, all
satisfying, and has repositioned me as an applied anthropologist with an
emphasis on community development. The program has grown in numbers, with
thirty people Ôon the groundÕ at various times last summer, and now involves
undergrads, grad students, faculty and professionals from several agencies and
institutions, as well as different disciplines. This paper will review projects
we have undertaken, including community organization, ecotourism, environmental
protection, computer education, oral history, heritage preservation, and
hydrology. I will also discuss the on-going process of defining our roles in
the community. One persistent question has been, what do anthropology majors
have to offer?
Bjorn
Westgard, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Hennepin County Medical
Center, 2-6
SPECTACULAR
HEALING: PERFORMING ETHNIC POLITICS THROUGH TRADITIONAL MEDICINE IN SENEGAL
Over the
last two decades in Senegal, the minority Sereer population has gained national
and international recognition through several spectacles of traditional
medicine that have been covered in national and international media. Located
near the geographic center of the nation, local politicians have parlayed these
prominent displays into further arguments about the centrality of Sereer
culture within the Senegalese nation. Many of these pleas have drawn on local
and communal knowledge, while also being used to opportunistically garner
larger portions of the national budget. In the eyes of many in central Senegal,
such uses of Sereer tradition aim to correct several decades of increasing
Wolof cultural dominance and to redress decades of neglect with regard to
national investments in local infrastructure. Yet Sereers have struggled to
reconcile the constraining local affinities that make traditional healing
possible with more gainful adaptations of seeing and sorcery exhibited in mediatized
performances. These negotiations have taken place through healing practice,
local forums, national media, academic conferences, and activities of the
governmental and non-governmental development community. Through these multiple
reconciliations between communal and mobile forms of traditional medical
knowledge, people in central Senegal have worked to simultaneously refashion a
communal but translocal ethnicity and polity.
Brian G
Lane, University of Cincinnati, 3-12
A
Paleoethnobotanical Study of Precolumbian Subsistence in the Middle Ohio Valley
Brian G.
Lane and David L. Lentz The first paleoethnobotanical investigations at Twin
Mounds Village (33Ha24) have produced new data on subsistence adaptations.
Samples were retrieved through implementation of a systematic recovery strategy
using water flotation applied to all excavated contexts within a deeply
stratified midden. This investigation focuses on role of plants in subsistence
practices and the other economic adaptations in the pre-Columbian Middle Ohio
River Valley. A considerable time depth at the site allows for a glimpse into
plant use activities that range from Early Archaic to Late Woodland times.
Analysis of botanical remains through the use of light and electron microscopy
has revealed the presence of several economic species, including Amaranthus
sp., Chenopodium berlandieri, and Juglans sp.
Brian
Montes, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2-6
"Un
Pueblo en Marcha": Performance and Protest among Maya Speakers of Felipe
Carrillo Puerto
In 1847 a
group of Maya, known today as the CruzoÕob or Chan Santa Cruz Maya, took part
in one of the largest and most successful indigenous uprisings in the Americas,
The Caste War of Yucat‡n. Led by indigenous leaders Jacinto Pat, Manuel Antonio
Ay, and Cecilio Ch’, the rebellion nearly drove the ruling aristocracy (Spanish
Creoles) from the peninsula. In 1901, however, General Bravo, under the
authority of Mexican President Porfirio D’az, set out to recover the Yucat‡n
Peninsula. Another battle ensued and by 1910 the CruzoÕob, for reasons
presently contested, retreated into the jungle dedicating their lives to the
reverence of a holy Òtalking crossÓ and to YucatanÕs Caste War. This
presentation examines the performances of two events, the ritualistic guarding
of the Òtalking crossÓ and the annual celebration of YucatanÕs Caste War that
takes place throughout the municipality of Felipe Carrillo Puerto in Quintana
Roo, Mexico. Through an analysis of the guarding of the cross and an analysis
of the annual celebration of Yucat‡nÕs Caste War, I demonstrate how both of
these events mobilize networks of social action that have transformed the
political landscape of Felipe Carrillo Puerto.
Brian
Mrozek, Loyola University Chicago,
2-15
The Ogham
Script.
The paper I
am sending to be reviewed for submission addresses my research on the ancient
Celtic alphabet of "Ogham". Research discussed on this topic involves
an in-depth definition of Ogham, the origin of the script, the Celtic trees in
regards to Ogham, the structure of the alphabet, and the Ogham stone
inscriptions found in Ireland. Ogham, pronounced "OH-am", was an
alphabetic writing system used for the Old Irish language in Celtic Ireland,
Wales, and Britain dating from around the third to sixth centuries CE. The
Ogham alphabet is a phonetic system consisting of fifteen consonants and five
vowels, and after the sixth century CE accrued five more letters. Most of the
occurrences of Ogham are found as stone inscriptions and are sepulchral in
nature. The names of the letters of this alphabet are thought to have
originated from twenty trees held to be sacred to the ancient people of the
area. This theory is skeptical, however, because some geographical evidence may
oppose this idea.
Brian R.
Selmeski, USAF Culture & Language Center, 2-7
Into the
Wild Cross-Cultural Yonder: Anthropology and the Transformation of Air Force
Professional Education
The US Air
Force has embarked on a bold and wide-ranging effort to enhance cross-cultural
learning for all uniformed personnel through the quality enhancement plan, an
integral part of academic re-accreditation. This presentation will briefly
describe the plan (developed by anthropologists), then examine the reactions of
Air Force leaders, Air University administrators, faculty and regional
accrediting officials. By examining multiple perspectives within the
institution, the key limitations and points of contention become more visible.
These include conceptual matters (e.g., what is culture?), philosophical issues
(e.g., what do we need this for?), practical concerns (e.g., how do we squeeze
this into an already full curriculum?) and methodological-epistemological
questions (e.g., how do we know when weÕve succeeded?). How the plansÕ
architects engaged these constituents and navigated their issues reveals not
only the plans strengths/weaknesses, but also how it is part of a larger effort
to transform professional military education.
Bryce
Peake, Brandeis University, 3-3
Sounding
Identity in Gozitan Restaurants
Much like
landscape, soundscape is a medium for human expression. People inscribe it with
meanings by marking it with instrumental, vocal, and even ambient aural sounds,
as well as using- or avoiding in some instances- certain aural representations.
In this paper, I examine the current state of soundscapes in Gozo, Malta, in
which sound is used to negotiate, refute, and promote various identities
amongst various audiences. The primary focus lies in examining the effects of
globalizing forces, such as tourism, on the perception of identity and the ways
in which Òthe authenticÓ is used to contest both globally and locally conceived
notions of the ÒGozitanÓ through sound. As groups seek to redefine themselves,
they alter globalized sounds to fit their own uses and notions of identity, and
thus, what is ÒGozitanÓ is voiced in different ways by different people for
different situations.
Caroline
Haggerty, Kenyon College, 3-16
When Worlds
Collide: Differing Interpretations of Catholicism in a Rural Honduran Community
Ethnographic
research conducted from January to May 2008 in the rural village of Pueblo
Nuevo, northwest Honduras revealed unanticipated divisions within the Catholic
community. Pueblo Nuevo is a mestizo town primarily composed of recent migrants
among whom interpersonal bonds are fluid. Central to ongoing processes of
building social networks is the debate over Catholic identity. Most Pueblo
Nuevo residents grew up Catholic yet differ strikingly on how that affiliation
is interpreted. This paper outlines the factions based on those differences,
which range from orthodox Catholicism, to an inculturated version of the faith,
to syncretic Catholicism combining indigenous and European elements. Attention
is paid to how basic disagreements about Catholicism are enacted and negotiated
in daily life and dramatically highlighted during Holy Week. The above
relationship of Catholicism to social dynamics is contrasted with the situation
in the more demographically stable, socially homogenous community of Petoa
1.5km to the south.
Catherine
Page
IUPUI
Museum Studies
2-12
Trustees of
the Sacred: Protecting, Maintaining, and Interpreting Sacred Sites
What sort
of standards and practices should museum professionals employ with Native
American sacred places? How should museums and other public institutions handle
disagreements about land usage? I will select three to five sacred sites in
North America, examining these places from the perspective of the Native
American cultures to which they are sacred and paying close attention to the
folklore surrounding the sites. I will look at land usage, particularly cases
where conflict has arisen. I will use my conclusions from all of the above
areas to synthesize some standards for museum professionals to use when working
with sacred places.
Ceara
Horsley, Southern Illinois University at Edwardsville, 1-1
Patrimony
and Paternalism? A Quantitative Analysis of NAGPRA Notices of Intent to
Repatriate
Since the
controversial inception of NAGPRA in 1990, there has been much published
literature both for and against the act, but very little quantitative analysis
of the actual repatriations, particularly the ethnographic items. Are some
artifacts more likely than others to be repatriated? Are some institutions more
or less likely to repatriate? Are there any trends in the tribes to which
artifacts are repatriated? To answer these questions, this study categorizes
and statistically analyzes the 16, 023 artifacts, the institutions and the
tribes in the 2007 NAGPRA Notices of Intent to Repatriate published in the
Federal Register. The study then compares this data to long term trends in the
institutions and tribes, as well as number of notices published in the Federal
Register from the inception of the act. This qualitative picture of trends in
NAGPRA notices of Intent to Repatriate provides one means through which we may
approach questions of compliance.
Christopher
Fennell, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 3-11
Aversive
Racism and Perverse Incentives in 19th Century Illinois
In addition
to overt acts of racism and racial violence, African-American communities in
the late 19th century combated various forms of aversive and structural racism
that diverted economic opportunities away from them and presented challenges
for households to overcome. This presentation will examine such dynamics using
examples from archaeological and historical analysis of three communities in
Illinois: the Equal Rights settlement outside Galena, New Philadelphia, and
Brooklyn. Research concerning such communities can expand our understanding of
how social networks, racism, and developing markets influenced the ways in
which individuals and households made choices in shaping their natural, social,
and built environments and in developing social and cultural traditions and
economic strategies. Civic engagement in such research projects also
significantly aids the members of current-day communities to enhance the
recognition and visibility of their African-American heritage and
accomplishments and to combat facets of structural racism they are experiencing
today.
Christopher
Sheklian, University of Chicago, 3-13
Redemptive
Projects and Revolutionary Politcs
Events such
as the World Trade Organization demonstrations in Seattle in 1999 suggest a
persistent global interest in revolutionary politics and while the
long-dominant strand of thought for most would-be revolutionaries has been
Marxism, there has been no dearth of alternatives. What I will argue is that
the redemptive promise of Marxism is what has given it such incredible
affective purchase as a revolutionary project. Moreover, I would like to
suggest that the ability of any revolutionary politics to attract adherents and
thrive depends largely upon this redemptive aspect of the project. To this end,
the paper will construct a broad Weberian ideal-type of Òredemptive project,Ó
drawing upon WeberÕs own work with religion and the theodicy question to
discuss the affective attachment of revolutionary politics as a redemptive
answer to the problem of evil in the world. I will look comparatively at
WeberÕs discussion of religion, Marxism, anarchism, and the green movement as
different Òredemptive projectsÓ in order to elucidate the emotional
relationship of the various projects to their adherents. The paper also
suggests the value of a Weberian ideal-type as a heuristic that operates in a
space that is simultaneously cognizant of anti-essentialist critiques of
grouping ÒreligionÓ with ÒpoliticsÓ in order not to suggest politics as
secularized religion but rather to ask how such varying projects produce
similar affective relationships. Finally, I would like to use the 1999 WTO
protests in Seattle ethnographically as an example of a redemptive project to
ask about the possibilities of revolutionary politics today.
Claude F.
Jacobs, University of Michigan-Dearborn, 3-1
Race,
Religion, and Rhetoric: The Language Community that Prophet Jones Built in
Detroit
James
Francis Marion Jones, born in 1907 in Birmingham, Alabama, began preaching at
the age of six and became a member of Triumph the Church and Kingdom of God in
Christ, an African American Holiness denomination. In 1938 he moved to Detroit
where by 1944, as Prophet Jones, he had established his own church, Universal
Triumph, the Dominion of God. Until his death in 1971 he was one of the city's
best known yet most controversial religious leaders. Prophet Jones' influence
spread beyond the borders of Michigan and he is reported to have established
churches in fifteen other staes, Liberia, and the Caribbean. His Detroit
congregation occupied a building that could accommodate 2,000 people, making it
one of the city's largest places of worship, and there were both television and
radio broadcasts of the services. It was through these broadcasts that Prophet
Jones became known for his preaching, and recordings of his sermons were made.
In creating a religious movement Prophet Jones also created a language
community with its own linguistic style and lexicon. Using Prophet Jones'
sermons along with archival material this paper examines Universal Triumph as a
language community set apart by its religious discourse not only from other
religious groups but also from significant segments of the rest of Detroit's
African American population.
Clementine
Fujimura, U.S. Naval Academy
2-7
On Being Motivated
and Other Challenges for Teaching Culture in a Military Academy
This paper
explores the way in which the culture concept is being taught at the United
States Naval Academy within the contexts of both training and education. Over
the years, USNA has struggled to graduate midshipmen who are cross-culturally
competent due to constraints of time and a focus in the curriculum on science
and engineering at the expense of language and cultural studies. In 2008 a
committee was formed to bring culture to all levels of the yard. In so doing
the culture concept has had to be modified dependent upon its presentation in a
variety of contexts from plebe summer training, to training in the dormitory
(hall) to discussion in the academic classroom. This paper discusses the pros
and cons of the implementation of Òculture across the curriculumÓ in a military
academy.
Costadina
Aneziris, University of Illinois at Chicago, 2-10
Experiences
of Living with Sickle Cell Disease and Treating Pain
As part of
a larger qualitative project focusing on the experiences of living with Sickle
Cell Disease (SCD), we interviewed patients attending UICÕs Adult and Pediatric
Sickle Cell Disease clinics. For this project, we focused on childhood and
current experiences and perspectives associated with living with this
particular genetic disease. However, for this presentation, we present data
that speaks to a number of themes centering on treatment and coping options. On
one end of the continuum, some patients strictly followed the advice of a
healthcare professional and at the other end, some patients chose alternatives.
From an analysis of more than 12 interviews, we noticed that experience seems
to play an important role in pain crisis detection and coping. We hope that
what we have learned from participants will help future generations. To
conclude, weÕll suggest a number of ways that knowledge transfer
(practitioner-patient; patient-patient, media-public) can be improved.
Daniel C.
Schneider, University of Illinois at Chicago, 2-10
Born With
It: Photographic Images of Life with Sickle Cell Disease
Sickle Cell
Disease (SCD) is a genetic disease affecting an estimated 70,000 people in the
USA. Approximately, 1,000-2,000 infants are born with SCD annually. In the USA,
the disease disproportionately affects African, African American, and South
Asian populations which, based on the USAÕs history of racism, undoubtedly
alters the SCD experience. Undoubtedly, this disease affects the lives of the
sufferers in multiple ways (socially, politically, economically, and
emotionally). We report on the Photo-Voice portion of the larger qualitative
study that was conducted to understand the SCD experience. Pediatric patients
were asked to narrate a series of photos they took that were supposed to represent
their lives and living with SCD. We analyze the themes symbolically captured in
the photographic images by the patients, including coping mechanisms, effects
on social relationships, socioeconomic effects of chronic disease, and an
analysis of the dynamics of biomedical treatment of Sickle Cell Disease.
David A.
McDonald, Indiana University, 2-2
Discussant
for Panel: "Performing the Political"
This dual
session explores the interrelationships of expressive cultural practices and
modalities of power relations. The first panel examines the staging of South
Caucasus political identities within the Eurovision Song Contest; the
performance of gender politics in traditional vocal music on the Greek island
of Skyros; the Burning Man Arts Festival as a rite of passage that pushes
participants to political action; and the power dynamics of honorific speech
and social greetings in encounters between Wa Buddhists and Han Chinese
authorities (Kipp, Glaros, Larkin, Liu). The second panel examines the
transformations of the Yucatan political landscape through commemorations of
indigenous Maya uprisings; childrenÕs participation in indigenous cow branding
rituals and their staged representations in highland Peru; the performance of
minority Sereer identity in "spectacles" of Senegalese traditional
medicine; and the interpretations and responses of rural villagers to the
Chinese stateÕs ÒhumaneÓ family planning project (Montes, Grim-Feinberg,
Westgard, Chen).
David
Perusek, Kent State University Ashtabula, 2-10
Cancer, Culture,
and Consciousness
From folk
beliefs about how cancer spreads within the body and why "they" have
yet to find a cure, to the cultural dimensions of personal condolances and the
class dimensions of media templates for "living with the disease",
this paper examines ways in which culture and culture bearers frame the
experience of cancer for patients and their families in the United States.Based
on participant-observation in the life of a family beset by 2 cancer diagnoses
and a premature death by cancer in the space of a year, the paper also examines
the hegemonic language of warfare and holocaust that shapes cancer discourse
and finds it afflicting the afflicted.
Denene De
Quintal, University of Chicago, 1-1
Native
American Museums in Southern New England and Authenticity
This paper
focuses on the part the Mashantucket Pequot Museum and Research Center plays in
creating an ÒauthenticÓ Native American identity in Southern New England. As
one of the largest Native Museums in the world, the museum has become the
epicenter for people who want to understand the cultures of Native people. The
museumÕs cultural education classes try to explain Northeastern Native cultures
and connect them to the larger Native American community. Native programming
also tries to build connections with other Native communities and establish the
Mashantucket Pequot as a part of the larger Native community. Although the
Pequot Museum is the largest and one of the wealthiest Native Museums in the
Northeast, it has not been able to quell opinions that Native Americans in
Southern New England are Òinauthentic.Ó The absence of Mashantucket tribal
members and the inexperience of museum workers create the perception that
Native people in Southern New England have lost their culture. In contrast,
smaller institutions such as the Tantaquidgeon Museum and Tomaquag Indian
Memorial have been able to validate the continuous presence of Native Americans
in the Southern New England. They may have less money, but this decreases their
dependence on non-Natives and Natives from outside of Southern New England to
represent them. They are able to share their own stories about their tribesÕ
presence in Southern New England. These museums have been successful in
maintaining the history of local Native communities as well as reaffirming the
presence of Native people in Southern New England.
Derek
Brereton, Adrian College, 1-2
Campsteading
and the Domestic Frontier: Rusticating New Hampshire
Campsteading
is characterized by the ownership through six to eight generations of property
and rustic pine cabins by single American families. This combines
intergenerational continuity, emplacedness, a rooted sense of self, and
consequent influences on landscape quality and open space preservation.
Campsteading amounted to a domestic colonization, for the properties chosen
were previously regarded as waste. It derived from American transcendentalism
and Civil War exhaustion, and is related to the arts and crafts and
back-to-nature movements through which some responded to the industrial
revolution. In turn, campsteads have been seminal in driving the local
environmentalist movements in central New Hampshire. This paper sketches out
the morphogenic relations between these social trends, and locates campsteading
as an important facet of social change and resistance in America.
Donald H.
Holly Jr., Eastern Illinois University, 2-9
Unearthing
Halloween
On
Halloween 1979, students at Eastern Illinois University excavated a time
capsule that had been buried a decade earlier and replaced it with one of their
own. Twenty five years later on Halloween 2004, some individual(s) laid
flowers, charms, coins and other items at the gravesite of a suspected 18th
century vampire in the town of Exeter, Rhode Island. This paper conveys the results
of material analyses of both events. Although these events share little in
common other than a date, the study of them underscores the common power of
archaeology to contribute new and different interpretations of the past.
Douglas
Caulkins, Grinnell College, 3-16
Cultural
Hybridity in the Welsh and Irish Diasporas
Theories of
cultural hybridity suggest that diasporic cultures will constitute a Òthird
space,Ó closely resemble neither the host culture nor the culture of origin.
Exploring this idea in a multi-site study of identity in Wales, Ireland, and
their American diasporas, we asked informants to evaluate the behavior in a set
of 21 scenarios or brief narratives that capture important cultural themes. The
responses were collected from two sites in Wales, two in Ireland, two
Welsh-American communities (in Iowa and the New York/Vermont border) and in one
Irish-American community in Nebraska. We assessed the degree of agreement among
the sites using cultural consensus analysis. While the profiles in the
Welsh-American communities closely resemble the Welsh sample, those in the
Irish-American community show little similarity to Ireland. The Òthird spaceÓ
characterization is supported in the Irish case, but not in the Welsh case.
Douglas
Midgett, Un iversity of Iowa, 2-9
Mann Gulch:
Ethnology, reconstructed history, oral sources, inference
Norman
MacleanÕs account of the 1949 Mann Gulch wildfire in Montana in 1949 has
provided source material for various interpretations and prescriptive analyses
of small group behavior and leadership from a number of disciplinary
perspectives. The initial event,
described in Young Men in Fire, in
which 12 Forest Service smokejumpers lost their lives, has suggested approaches
to understanding group responses to crisis situations that have drawn the
attention of business organization analysts, designers of employee training
programs, and student of cognition and creative thinking. Because these scholars, struck by the
completeness of MacleanÕs account, have used his rendition as ÒethnographyÓ of
an event, and because we often use the same resources as he did to do
ethnographic reconstructions, I want to examine the manner in which we assemble
these reconstructions and how we make inferences about what happened and, more
importantly, how and why.
Duane
Kahler, University of Central Missouri, 3-2
The
Straight Edge
ÒThe
Straight EdgeÓ is an analysis of an extant, vibrant subculture in the
underground hardcore punk rock scenes across the United States. Straight Edge
subculture is directly connected to a music scene that developed in the early
1980s in response to the cultural norms of the Òrock and roll lifestyle.Ó
Individuals in this subculture make a personal pact to abstain from alcohol,
smoking, drugs, and promiscuous sex. Despite media biases and misconceptions
about Straight Edge, the subculture continues to develop as both a musical and
cultural antithesis to commonly held stereotypes about punk rock fandom.
Through ethnographic research and participant observation, this author will
present personal accounts of members of the Straight Edge community, provide
insight into the emic meaning(s) of Straight Edge, examine the development of
Straight Edge as a subculture, and discuss how stereotypes about Straight Edge
have stigmatized the Straight Edge community.
Ehren
Lichtenwalter, Andrews University, 2-15
In the
Middle of Nowhere and at the Crossroads of Everywhere: Abatement and Change at Tall Hisban,
332-63 BCE
The purpose
of this study is to fine-tune the resolution on our picture of Tall Hisban in
Jordan during the Hellenistic Period. In order to do this, I will approach the
settlement using LaBianca's abatement framework--an appropriate approach
considering the occurrence of abatement at Tall Hisban during the Hellenistic
Period, lasting from 332-63 BCE. The specific components contained in the
abatement framework (accumulating hazards, lost opportunities,
hyperintegration, myopic policies, underdevelopment and food shortages, and
epidemics) will be considered alongside existing archaeological, historical,
and anthropological evidence in order to construct a clearer picture of what
might have brought about the period of abatement. In addition, this study will
hypothesize what the effects of abatement at Hisban might have been--that is
how abatement impacted the settlement's agricultural, social, economic,
political, and cultural interactions. Specifically, the study will focus on the
social and cultural relations that occurred within the settlement and in the
periphery during the period of abatement. My study will draw on field reports
from Tall Hisban and historical accounts pertinent to the region and period
under study. Essentially, this is a study of how a simple hilltop settlement in
the Transjordan hinterland evolved in the face of changing circumstances.
Elise
Berman, University of Chicago, 3-10
Culture and
Uses of Immaturity: Marshallese Children as Moral Liars
Anthropologists
generally agree that childhood differs across cultures. At the same time,
however, we recognize that people everywhere identify a portion of their
population as immature, i.e., not yet fully capable. What value, if any, do
children carry in society as a function of their immaturity? I tackle this
question by examining how children act as moral subjects in a village in the
Republic of the Marshall Islands. In the Marshalls, good people are Christian
people and Christian people do not lie. But, children are not even considered
capable of being Christian until they reach a certain state of maturity. As I
will show, because children are not seen as responsible for their words, they
can lie without being considered bad people or bad Christians. An ideology of
children as immature and not-capable, therefore, paradoxically gives children
the ability to do things that adults cannot, in turn giving them a unique role
to play in social life. Through acting in ways only available to the immature,
Marshallese children affect kinship ties, social relations, and peopleÕs
reputations. Hence, I suggest that cultures, in different ways according to
different ideologies of childhood and immaturity, make use of childrenÕs
paradoxical status: children are influential precisely because they are not
seen as such.
Elizabeth
Sobel and Chris Cotter, Missouri State University, 1-5
A
Collaborative Study of the Role of Long Island, WA, in Chinookan Identity and
Culture
In 2006, we
began collaborating with the Chinook Nation to study the role of Long Island,
Washington, among the Chinookan people from pre-contact through modern times.
The project was designed to serve cultural heritage preservation goals of the
Chinook Nation and answer anthropological questions about indigenous cultural
persistence. Our methodology involved archaeological field work, oral history
interviews, and archival research. The results indicate that Long Island has
remained significant in Chinookan culture and identity from the pre-contact
through modern eras. However, the basis of that significance has shifted over
time. While the IslandÕs immediate economic importance has diminished, its
political and symbolic importance have increased. These findings highlight the
critical link between continuity and change in Native cultural survival; change
at one level facilitates continuity at other levels. The Chinook Nation may now
use the results in support of several efforts, including their century-long
quest for federal recognition.
Emma
Lawler, Grinnell College, 3-7
Gendered
Bodies as Sites of Opression and Empowerment
This paper
explores ways that the body is a space of negotiation of social and individual
power, looking specifically at how womenÕs bodies simultaneously experience
oppression and empowerment. A book of personal narratives written by 29 women
from Grinnell College will be used as ethnographic data of personal narrative
about bodies and oneÕs own body. Comaroff and Comaroff (1992) set up a paradigm
of the body as Òtemplate and toolÓ; that will be applied to and analyzed by the
content of the narratives. Within these narratives, I will look for and
identify two primary theoretical orientations of the body-- the body as symbol
and agent – to demonstrate the fluidity in these orientations as they are
personally experienced in womenÕs understandings of their own body. These
college student womenÕs narratives bear witness to the ways in which womenÕs
bodies are a form of speech (Ellmann 1993). The form of ethnography, personal
narrative, is especially important here as an acknowledged place of agency and
voice, placing the narratives as a political action. I examine the ways that
the narratives mirror and discuss the body as speech.
Eric
Hartzold, Illinois State University, 3-15
Material
Consumption and American University Students
In this
paper I present results from a ongoing research project of material consumption
by midwestern American college students conducted by a university faculty
member and me. Through interviews, surveys, and artifact analysis we examine
how students view their relationship with everyday consumable items, and
attempt to determine how they cognitively and behaviorly define notions like
appropriate use, waste, recycling, and disposability. The design of the
research, the obstacles encountered, and preliminary findings are reported. We
discuss and compare our findings in relation to broader global environmental
issues—such as the barriers and dilemmas faced by a well-intended
consumer forced to live in a materialist consumer culture. Finally, we describe
how this project articulates with ongoing environmental agendas at the university,
and how it will be used for further work.
Erin Kenny,
Drury University, 1-5
International
Service-Learning: A Thoroughly Gendered Case Study from JamaicaÓ
In recent
years, educators are increasingly concerned with developing teaching models
that help students become more intentional and integrated in their learning:
international service-learning in study abroad programs may assist students in
developing habits of mind that prepare them to make informed personal,
professional, and civic decisions throughout their lives. Anthropologists are
uniquely suited to lead these learning initiatives, and to both tailor and
implement content-based, service-learning rubrics that collaborate with local
civic leaders and correspond to the needs of local communities. In this
cautionary case study, I discuss challenges and learning outcomes from a
summer, 2008 study abroad trip in Bluefields, Jamaica, as well as reflecting
briefly on the nature of cross-cultural gender challenges in the field and the
potential rewards of leading such a trip as a feminist anthropologist. I also
suggest that students themselves (as peer educators) may ultimately be the best
ambassadors in a campus community for promoting and developing integrated
service-learning programs.
Evin
Rodkey, University of Illinois at Chicago, 3-13
Transnationalism
of a Different Color: Negotiating Deportation in the Dominican Republic
Globalized
labor has created transnational communities that connect the U.S. and other
nations (Basch, et al. 1994; Goldin 1999). However, each year thousands of
these migrants are returned to their country of birth after facing deportation
for conviction of a crime. Many of these deportees migrated to the U.S. as
children and became long-term residents. Changes to immigration law are
subjecting even legal permanent residents with minor criminal convictions to
deportation. My ethnographic research explores the economic and social
strategies these deportees use to survive in the Dominican Republic after
spending a near-lifetime in the U.S. Furthermore, I investigate the increasing
influx of deportees into Dominican neighborhoods and the social and economic
impact this has on the local communities. As former long-term U.S. residents,
the unique transnational experiences of these deportees demand greater
attention if we are to fully understand the range of transnational movement
produced by globalization and the outcomes of the deportation system that
connects the U.S. and communities abroad. After a U.S. upbringing and an
arrival in the country of birth marked by a criminal record, the circumstances
of these deportees challenge our current characterizations of transnational
livelihoods. By examining the economic and social strategies deportees use in
the country of birth, this research brings to light the myriad ways deportees
construct their lives after deportation, advancing our understanding of
transnationalism.
Gaelyn
Aguilar, The University of Akron, 2-1
Maravat’o
Resounding
Building
upon my interest in transnationalism, and extending my interest in performance
into that of performing what JosŽ Lim—n calls Òan archaeology of subjugated
knowledges and practices,Ó I have just begun a research initiative linking
Maravat’o, Mexico with Akron, Ohio. The preliminary stage of this project took
place this October in Maravat’o, where I co-facilitated a remapping of the
town. Inspired by ÒSituationist InternationalÓ and the psycho-geographical
movement of the 1960s, this two-day workshop brought together a collective of
individuals interested in identifying the multitude of historical, social, and
personal layers/narratives of Maravat’o, a place of transnational significance.
Tapping into the conceptual impulse behind derivŽ—the act of Òdropping
oneÕs usual motivation for movement and actionÓ in order to (re)discover space
and place—we took GPS coordinates of three sites in Akron, Ohio where
Mexican transnationals gather, and transposed them onto a map of Maravat’o in
order to build interconnections among geophysical, political, and social relationships.
As we walked our remapped route, we interacted with whomever/whatever we
encountered, and documented what we experienced through a range of media,
including photography, audio, paper and pen. Maravat’o Resounding is a
reflection of my growing interest in applied work that engages issues that are
in dialogue with the social sciences and humanities. Recent projects come from
disparate moments and geographic locations, and reflect an ethos that connects
cultural production with community engagement. My presentation will focus on
how I am utilizing such projects to facilitate such an ethos.
George
Calfas, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 3-12
Look before
you Dig: Non-intrusive measure to Archaeology
Recent
field work conducted at the National Historic Site of New Philadelphia Illinois
has utilized ground-based electric resistivity and fluxgate magnetometer in
combination with high resolution thermal imaging from a low altitude aerial
platform. This poster presentation will show the correlation between the
non-intrusive in-ground and aerial surveying techniques and the cultural
materials found at the New Philadelphia site. The town site is currently
situated beneath 42 acres of agricultural and prairie landscape; inserting
units based only on walkover surveys and oral histories could often yield mixed
results. The use of these additional remote sensing techniques has increased
the confidence level for an excavation unit being placed at the location of
cultural material and building foundations. The research team has been able to
increase their work efficiency and effectiveness by placing excavation units at
mapped anomalies that were displayed on one or more of these remote sensing
surveying methods.
Gerald L.
Carr, University of Michigan, 3-17
Making
"Heritage" in the Yukon
In the
Yukon Territory of Canada, land claims and self-governing agreements have
settled many issues for indigenous First Nations, but the discussions of
heritage, and the control of heritage, remain ambiguous. But what is meant by
heritage? How were aboriginal beliefs and practices in the Yukon transformed
into this object of contemplation, this set of identity-marking practices, and
charged node in the network of local power relations? When did heritage become
something that could be owned, threatened, lost, or revitalized? In this paper
I develop a genealogy of the concept of heritage as negotiated and deployed in
the Yukon. From the local, grassroots efforts in the 1970Õs that eventually led
to the landmark Umbrella Final Agreement in 1993, to the current debates about
indigenous rights and world heritage in the UN system, a dialectic of
globalization and localization is apparent in this example from the heritage
wars.
Grace M.
Varghese, Westminster College, 3-11
Interplay
between Caste and Race in India
The Hindu
caste system influences and is influenced by class, power and race. In
particular there is significant overlap between class stratification and race.
This paper explores how phenotypical variations (race) plays an important part
in the Indian caste system by creating boundaries, such as marriage groups, and
even creating expected images of people associated with a certain Varna. I will
address the Indian association between skin tone and Varna, inclining Indians to
expect Brahmans to have the fairest skin. This leads to Sanskritization where
most members of Indian society want to have fair skin to be like the Brahmans,
and raise the status of their caste.
Greta
Kliewer, Kansas State University, 3-3
Maltese
Bread: Changing Symbol of the Island's Identity
Food and
culture – it is nearly impossible to separate these aspects of the way
people live. The way we prepare, consume, and talk about food says a lot about
who we are, and distinguishes us as human. On the island of Gozo, Malta, the
production of hobz tal-Malti (Maltese bread) has become a symbol not only of
sustenance, but also identity. Breadmaking has been transformed from a social
activity in traditional bakeries to an isolated activity in homes and supermarkets.
Some Maltese believe this change has resulted in the detriment of their
cuisine, and consequently the culture from which it originated. For this
reason, cultural tourism projects in Malta are seeking to preserve the physical
and cultural traditions of producing Maltese bread. This single examination of
a staple in GozitansÕ diet functions as a window into the dynamic relationship
between the way people live and the food they eat.
Heather
Stanislowski, Univeristy of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, 2-15
The Beauty
of Bog Bodies
Ever since
the recorded discovery of a bog body in 1640, these enigmatic and miraculously
preserved mummies have plagued the minds of archaeological researchers. Who are
they? How did they die? Over the centuries we have tended to inscribe our own
beliefs and customs on these remains and their fascination lies in the remains
themselves as well as in the bogs where they are found. This paper will draw on
recent approaches to the archaeology of the body, focusing on elements of
personal ornament and clothing found on or near the bodies, which are not in
fact always nude. Analyzing these additional clues may provide us with new
insights into the bog bodies and why they continue to intrigue us today.
Heidi
Savery, Binghamton University, 1-5
The Management
and Marketing of JamaicaÕs Past: Community Archaeology and Heritage Tourism
Recent
trends in tourism indicate that consumers are largely interested in connecting
with culture and heritage, both their own and others. A priority has been set
in JamaicaÕs national agenda to seize opportunities arising from international
trends surrounding heritage interests in tourism. The development of heritage
resources into products of tourism requires a more inclusive, relevant view of
the past. One community on JamaicaÕs south coast has recently launched a
heritage initiative. Through its community archaeology component, the areaÕs
cultural resources are being explored and interpreted by a wide variety of
stakeholders. Such collaboration is just the type of positive vehicle needed to
achieve the sustainable development outlined by Jamaican cultural policies and
tourism action plans. Further collaboration with tourism interests and
development will hopefully result in more creative, multi-dimensional
presentations of the knowledge surrounding these tangible pieces of the past
combined with sustainable local development. The most valuable kind of heritage
is the product of self-representation.
Hyunhee
Kim, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 3-11
Contesting
Law: The Conflicts of Korean Immigrants in New York City
This paper
investigates how Korean immigrants construct, challenge, and reinforce the
boundary between legality and illegality, based on an ethnographic research on
the Korean immigrant community in New York City. The paper illustrates that
Korean immigrantsÕ perceptions of and relationships with legality are shaped
and influenced by their racial experiences. Korean greengrocers in New York
City experienced the labor conflict with Latino workers in recent years. In
this conflict, the Korean greengrocers were accused of violation of state labor
laws by overworking and underpaying predominantly Latino workers. The labor
conflict was highlighted as an ÒethnicÓ conflict between Koreans and Latinos in
the news media and reinforced the racial image of Korean entrepreneurs as
exploiting other minorities as in the Black-Korean conflict. I emphasize that
the incorporation of Koreans to the U.S. economy as small entrepreneurs has
structured the relationships of the Koreans with other racial minorities.
Furthermore, the place of Koreans in the U.S. economy has affected their
perceptions and use of law. I argue that while the Korean greengrocers contest
the labor laws as a means of disciplining Korean immigrants, they reinforce the
hegemony of law by accepting the discourse of Òillegal aliensÓ and supporting
existing racial and class hierarchies. My research shows that KoreansÕ
boundary-making between legality and illegality is contingent on and reflects
their position in racial politics.
Jack
Glazier, Oberlin College, 3-17
Grand
Delusion: An Anthropologist Looks at the Jefferson Davis Bicentennial
Jefferson
Davis, first and only president of the Confederacy, was born in what is now the
tiny hamlet of Fairview, Kentucky on June 3, 1808. A century later, plans were
set for the construction of the monument that now dominates DavisÕs birthplace.
About two thirds the height of the Washington Monument, the Davis obelisk was
completed in 1924, with funds from the state of Kentucky and the United
Daughters of the Confederacy. Local Klansmen burned a cross at the dedication.
Now operated by the Kentucky Department of Parks, the monument and surrounding
park are the site of a Davis celebration every June 3rd that in the recent past
has featured a Civil War battle reenactment, a Miss Confederacy contest, a film
showing, ÒWarriors of HonorÓ (an encomium to General Robert E. Lee), and a
place to gather for celebrants of the ÒLost Cause.Ó Marking the bicentennial of
DavisÕs birth, the celebration in early June 2008 extended the events of the
annual commemorations. This paper focuses on the public management of the
bicentennial by the state, which walks a narrow line between preserving a
legitimate historical site and preventing the use of the park to rally support
for extremist causes. Nonetheless, the bicentennial and recent annual
commemorations perpetuate Confederate ideology, portraying Davis as a faithful
Constitutionalist and purging the question/issue of race from any consideration
of the causes or consequences of the Civil War.
Jack
Thornburg, Benedictine University, 1-8
Market-led
Development Versus Basic Needs and the Public Good: The Role of Common Property
in St. Lucia
This paper
examines the failure of market-led development to provide adequate access to
the basic needs of those in St. Lucia in the Caribbean and more generally in
the Third World. The past several years has witnessed a shift in development
focus from state intervention in the development process to a reliance on
direct foreign investment in such areas as tourism and off-shore assembly. The
hoped-for outcome of such direct investments is an increase in employment
opportunities and state revenue. For several years the government has pushed
for greater privatization of common property arrangements known as family land
where land is owned jointly by descendents of the original landowner. Such
joint ownership has given access to land resources to many low income
individuals under conditions where land is scarce and expensive. It is the
contention of this paper that the cyclic nature of market-led development along
with its vulnerability to international economic downturns suggests that family
land is significant as a resource by providing access to land for those experiencing
economic difficulties. The state, therefore, should treat family land as a
Òpublic goodÓ since family land tenure has the potential to accommodate many
more people than a privatized system of individual holdings. This paper will
examine the condition of family land in the context of the uncertainties
engendered by market-led modernization and argue that family land needs to be
supported as a Òsocial securityÓ resource. Within this context the paper will
discuss James ScottÕs ÒmoralÓ economy and the issues of social justice in
calling for a new Òpeople-centeredÓ form of development.
Jacquelyn
A. Lewis-Harris, University of Missouri-St. Louis, 1-1
Navigating
Cook's Return: negotiating the presentation of early Hawiian and Pacific
artifacts
Relationships
between indigenous populations and local cultural institutions while often
positive, can also be laden with perceived social injustice concerns. This
paper addresses cultural anthropology's role in the mediation between Hawaiian
and Pacific Islanders community and a Honolulu based museum. Central to this
conversation was the return and display of Pacific Island objects collected by
Captain James Cook on the 1768-79 voyages. How do you encourage formerly
disenfranchised Hawai'ian and Pacific Islanders to participate in an exhibition
that glorifies early European exploration of their homelands? How do you
negotiate between the many layers of perceived and real social stratification
between "the locals", the descendants of plantation owners, pakia and
ruling elite as well as Hawai'ian and Pacific royalty? Issues of
ownership,representation and the agency of private-public institutions in
object interpretation, were interlaced with social justice concerns of status,
cultural alienation, identity and Hawi'ian sovereignty. This was the first time
that the Pacific Island community had been so intricately involved in
exhibition and event planning at the Honolulu Academy of Arts, a private
institution founded by Anna Cook. The work of Ivory(1999,)Herle(2002),and
Bonshek(2002)address the importance of Pacific Islanders inclusion in museum
interpretation,exhibition planning and addressing community concerns in
museums. Referencing their research,I will also discuss the community education
programs designed to address the social justice issues connected to the
exclusion of the Hwaiian homeland population and other disenfranchised Pacific
Islanders. The positive results of reflective negotiations in addressing the
inherent justice issues in this project will provide a guideline for
reproducing this approach in other communities with similar social and cultural
dynamics.
James A.
Johnson, University of Pittsburgh, 2-12
Archaeology
and the Social Prison: Transnational subjects and the governance of knowledge
Over the past
20 years, archaeologists have had to rethink the ways in which they communicate
with indigenous communities and, more generally, present information to the
general public about the past. Despite the development of better lines of
communication between some archaeologists and native communities, the more
deeply embedded problems of how the archaeological record is interpreted and
how such interpretations are then presented to and represented in museums
persist. Recently, it has been suggested in essays from a volume edited by
Thomas Killion that these problems include: 1) truth versus validity, 2) claims
of one past versus many (multivocality) and 3) Western science as asymmetrical
relations of power (Bray 2008; Zimmerman 2008). It is suggested in this paper
that these problematic aspects of archaeological interpretation can be
productively (re)investigated through alternative models that re-conceptualize
power as not only existing in asymmetrical relations but instead, more
generally, human social action. In the proposed paper, I draw upon models of
locality and community to critically examine data gleaned from a small
collection of bone and antler tools from the Swiss late Neolithic (3800-3250
BC) to confront issues of power and representation in not only contemporary
museum practice, but also in the deconstruction and (re)formation of
archaeological knowledge and truth claims.
James W.
Dow, Oakland University, 3-8
How
Evolution Created God
The easiest
way of understanding religion is through the eyes of a believer. However, a
non-believer often cannot accept this vision because it refers to beings and
forces that he or she cannot independently verify. Religion is even more of a
puzzle to the scientist, who is taught to believe only in a reality that can be
observed and tested. Yet, religion exists in the minds and hearts of people.
How did it get there if it was not implanted by a divine being? Natural
selection is the only process that science knows of that can produce a brain
that experiences religion. The the nature of this selection process is still
unclear. One way of discovering it is through mathematical and agent-based
simulation. This paper will present an agent-based model for the natural
selection of unreal beliefs and the potential for further simulation using
mathematics.
Jami Beach,
Wichita State University, 2-4
Community
Mosques: A glimpse into a Midwestern Islamic society
This is an
informational paper based on personal experience during several visits to
different local community Mosques. It has been prepared with an objective of
providing first hand insight into a Midwestern Islamic societyÕs differences
and similarities. Included is a detailed description of the buildings, people,
and insights that were experienced throughout my research, along with a
comparison between the different local communities that were studied.
Jamie
Zuehl, Vanderbilt University, 3-6
Cheap
Jeans, Cable TV, and Costumbre: Competing Discourses on Womanhood in a Mayan
Community
Eating
disorders are generally considered "diseases of civilization"
associated with Western obsessions with thinness. However, recent scholarship
finds populations in developing countries increasingly at risk. This study
examines body image among adolescent KÕicheÕ Maya women in Je'l Juyub', Guatemala,
where new media and commercial influences are intersecting with indigenous
cultural orientations that formerly did not emphasize narrow beauty
definitions. Utilizing cognitive tests and round-table discussions among a
sample of 35 KÕicheÕ adolescent girls, this study explores how KÕicheÕ girls
grapple with competing discourses on womanhood and beauty. Though preferences
continue for ÒnormalÓ body types seen as healthy, weight and shape concerns
linked to celebrity images are growing in tandem with commercial markets for
diet and style products. The study highlights issues for eating disorders
research in transitional communities encountering Western media and the
commoditization of beauty.
Janet Eads,
Illinois State University, 1-6
An
Anthropological Perspective on Great Ape Captivity and Biomedical Research
As is well
known, the living African Great Apes (chimpanzees, bonobos, and gorillas) are
our closest living relatives. And the placement of apes in zoos, and their use
for entertainment value or medical research, is also common knowledge. In this
paper I examine how—and why—humans have exploited these animals in
spite of the many obvious morphological similarities and overlapping patterns
of social behavior. I also ethnographically explore the Òape rights movement,Ó
a loose confederation of individuals and organizations advocating the granting
of technical legal human rights to many non-human primate species. I argue that
those who choose to exploit apes for perceived greater human good are not simply
Òspeciests,Ó nor are ape rights advocates the sole occupiers of the moral high
ground. Rather, to be truly ethical beings we need to take into account our
ability to tolerate cognitive dissonance, and to realize that culture—the
acceptance as natural of illogical and even counterproductive beliefs—is
also part of what it means to be human.
Jason
Shepard, Missouri State University, 2-13
Towards a
Typology of (Im-)Migrants in the US
Recognizing
the possibility that a typology can easily become a stereotype that obfuscates,
or worse, the tendency of public rhetoric and often policy to treat the
diversity of migrants within the United States as a monolithic group that
somehow exists beyond shared origins outside of the United States makes the
development of a typology a necessary danger. Individuals cannot simply be
classed as migrants and treated as a uniform entity. The structure of different
migrant families, their motives for migrating, and the work, communities, and
lives that they leave and come to must be considered if effective and sensitive
policies and programs are to be developed for migrants and the evolving and
escalating nature of migration is to be understood. A flexible and overlapping
typology of migrants is a foundational step in this process. All typologies,
taxonomies, and other systems of classification are artificial constructs, so,
in an effort to avoid arbitrary or useless divisions, the question becomes one
of utility. To create a typology distinctions must be made. What is the utility
of each distinction? How do conceptual boundaries help elucidate a scenario or
dynamic, what do they reveal and what might they obfuscate? It is with these
concerns in mind, that this limited and provisional typology of contemporary
migrants into the U.S. will be proposed. Far from being an exhaustive list, the
typology is intended as an opening line in a dialog to produce a usable
classification system that will aid in policy development, promote pluralism by
raising awareness, and assist in the effective planning and efficient
administration of programs and projects aimed at migrant and immigrant
populations. Refinements and additions are needed, especially where such
efforts can be supported by case studies and well developed theoretical models.
Jennifer
Baldwin, Wheaton College, 1-4
The
Evidence of Trauma: Substantiating a Theory of Personhood, Citizenship, and
War-acquired Disability
With large
numbers of soldiers returning with war-acquired disabilities, there is a
critical need to understand the veteranÕs disability experience, as well as the
space that these soldiers, their bodies, and their lives occupy within the
nation. Biomedical renderings of war-acquired disabilities fail to capture the
social and embodied meanings associated with the experience of such
disabilities. Trauma
theory offers a framework for structuring the experience of disabilities
considered traumatic to both body and subjectivity. By attending to the body as an analytical category and site
of embodied and discursive practices, this paper examines what counts as
evidence of war-acquired disabilities and trauma when seeking to understand the
veteransÕ experiences of war-acquired disabilities, provide care to this
population, and advance disability rights.
Jennifer
Rideout, Jenna Ely, and Elizabeth Sobel, Missouri State University, 3-12
Contact-Period
Shifts in Native American Exchange Systems: Obsidian Evidence From the Lower
Columbia
European
contact affected major shifts in Native North American exchange systems.
Anthropologists widely argue that among Northwest Coast peoples, these shifts
involved increases in the intensity, geographic scope, and elite monopolization
of exchange. However, this dominant model is based largely on ethnographic and
historical studies; a lack of relevant archaeological research precludes
rigorous evaluation of the model. We begin to redress this gap through an
archaeological analysis of remains from Cathlapotle, a Chinookan town site
along the Columbia River (WA state), inhabited AD 1400-1830. Our study focuses
on artifacts made of obsidian, an exotic stone Native peoples imported to
Cathlapotle. We test the dominant model by comparing pre-contact and
post-contact obsidian artifacts in terms of abundance, distance to geographic
sources, and differential household access. Our findings lead us to refine the
traditional model of contact-period exchange dynamics, and of related social
and political processes, for at least this area.
Jennifer
Thompson, Westminster College, 3-7
Social
Boundaries: In Group and Out Group Status According to Body Modification
Artists
This paper
explores the creation and maintience of in group/out group boundaries and
relationships through the process of body modification in a small town,
midwestern tattoo shop. I will examine the structural and ethnosemantic
categories that tattoo artists use to identify and understand themselves and
various types of customers. I will also examine how the artists think about and
categorize the various types of people without tattoos.
Jens Kreinath,
Wichita State University, 2-4
Veiled
Politics: How WomenÕs Veiling Challenge Turkish Secularism
In times of
globalization and communication technologies, the media play a crucial role for
public discourses and political decision processes in negotiating local issues.
One such issue that in recent times drew public media attention was the debate
on the appearance of veiled women in public institutions of Turkey As one of
the most obvious and rigidly achieved markers of this project of modernity and
secularism in Turkey, clothing reform forbid the display or wearing of any form
of religious symbols in public office. From its rise to power, the wives of AKP
politicians pushed the sensitive ÔbuttonÕ of veiled politics by presenting
themselves ÔcoveredÕ by head scarves during official state acts. The aims of
your paper should be two: first, to voice the different religious and political
agendas involved in the negotiations over the secularism of Turkish politics,
and, second, to analyze the role of public media in commenting upon these legal
and political negotiations in creating a public discourse. How have the media
created a public discourse about this contentious issue, and how are these
imaginaries used by various political agents constituted attempts to (in-)form
public opinion?
Jessica
Gergely, University of Lethbridge, 3-3
Performing
Gozitan Festivals: Authenticity and the Effects of Tourism
GozoÕs open
door culture is not something recently created; but is something that is in the
line of being exploited by tourism since joining the European Union. Women
still run lace out front of their door steps with other women in their village.
A wandering tourist can also still see men carving wooden ÒbobbinsÓ (spools for
lace) and tailor-men working in their small shops off the beaten track.
Gozitans give off a warm welcome and do not mind if the wandering tourist stops
for a moment to watch. They understand it is Festa that is what has brought
them to Gozo. Festa is a week long celebration of a communityÕs patron saint.
But after the smoke clears from the celebratory fireworks tourists vacate the
host community and return to an area of the island after fulfilling their
desire of an ÒauthenticÓ Maltese Festa experience. As the tourists disappear
from the streets the local Festa continues early into the morning hours. My
photo essay takes a look at Festa from a local view point and a glimpse of Gozo
daily life.
Jessica
Hopper, University of Wisconsin – Milwaukee, 3-3
Navigating
the Space of Language: Authorized Language and Symbolic Power in Gozo
In
examining the concepts of authoritative language and symbolic power we often
look to one legitimate language placed at the top of a hierarchy that serves to
marginalize all others, and in so doing, marginalizes its speakers. We look at subversive moments of
resistance to challenge this structure, but more often than not, it would seem,
this hierarchical structure of language is the one that prevails. It is important, therefore, to examine
language spaces that serve as a counterpoint or a place where the hierarchy
isnÕt so black and white. The
situational context of the dual language system of Malta provides just such
juxtaposition, within which to study authoritative language, symbolic power,
and strategies of condescension, as it is a place where the normal rules of
language hierarchy do not apply.
My research and field experience in Malta indicates that while English
may be given primacy on a global level, the local reality gives legitimacy to
Maltese. While strategies of
condescension in the use of English abound, there are still ways to negotiate
moments of power and meet in the middle.
Jim Sauls
and Bryan Alvarez, Illinois State
University, 3-15
ÒHey,
WhatÕs That Big Grey Building Over There?Ó: The Changing Role of the Library in
the Lives of University Students
ABSTRACT
(150 words or less): In this
paper, we present preliminary results of an ethnographic study of a Midwestern
university library. This research is a collaborative effort between two
undergraduate students, a faculty member, and a university librarian. Library
administrators commissioned this study because of the changing nature of
student research needs and study habits within todayÕs abundant information
environment, and the need of a university library to keep abreast of these
changes. While it is no surprise that Òthe bookÓ—and studentsÕ relation
to it—is in a dynamic state of flux, the library as a repository of
information and center for social-intellectual activity has been remarkably
constant, in spite of many cosmetic changes and the advent of new media. We
report our research design and our preliminary findings, and discuss them in
relation to similar studies of university libraries at other institutions. We
also connect our findings to larger social and pedagogical issues, such as how
students use new information technologies for their academic work. This
research is the beginning of an ongoing project, which will be used by this
particular library to guide reforms and renovations.
Joe Fishburn,
College of Wooster, 3-1
Religious
Dimension of the Alien Contact Experience
Millions of
people have claimed to have been contacted or abducted by aliens since the
1950s, yet this "exotic" Western Phenomenon is often overlooked as
undeserving of serious scholarly study.
The purpose of this project is to understand how personal narratives of
alien abduction and contact shape the social and cultural reality of the
witness. By focusing on religious
aspects of the alien experience, Ihope to convince others that this phenomenon
serves the same function as a religious experience, but is understood within a
rational and secular cultural context.
The alien contact experience serves as a religious experience as it touches
on humanity's most fundamental concerns, and involves aliens in human creation,
human existence, and the future of humanity. The contactee integrates aliens into understandings of
ultimate reality and significant life-changing experiences.
Joel Zovar,
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2-12
Collas,
Colonials, and Lacunae: Representations of Indigenous Political Agency in
Bolivian Museums
Bolivia is
a country whose majority population is Indigenous. This population has
historically been oppressed and has occupied the lowest stratum of the social,
political and economic hierarchy. Therefore, it is not surprising that museums
do not address the agency of Indigenous peoples during the transformative
colonial and republican periods (1533-1930) of the nationÕs past and, instead,
relegate the powerful, and political, Indian to prehistory. In this paper, I
examine three museums in the department of La Paz: the Museo Nacional de
Arqueolog’a, the Museo de Tiwanaku, and the Museo de la Revoluci—n. Each
differs in terms of the voice of authority scripting the exhibitions, which
vary in temporal focus. I examine the ways in which Indigenous peoples are
represented, and interrogate the impact of lacunae in historical
representations on the cumulative presentation of Indigenous identity. I
suggest that omissions and misrepresentations in museums today have their
origins in the Colonial and republican periods in which an Òideological spaceÓ
precluded the category of the politically solvent Indigene and, instead,
shifted Indigenous political identity solely to prehistory in order to
legitimize the state. This Òideological spaceÓ remains unchallenged in Bolivian
museums, suggesting the continuation of a colonial fiction that reduces
contemporary Indigenous political momentum to an historical anomaly without
antecedents much beyond the 1952 Agrarian Revolution, effectively severing the
publicÕs perception of Indigenous political roots in antiquity. The
implications of this situation on contemporary Bolivian Indigeneity are
considered, especially in light of dramatic social activism, violence, and
racism in the years leading up to and following the election of BoliviaÕs first
Indigenous president in 2005.
John
Michels, University of Illinois at Chicago, 3-13
The
Gentrification of the Canadian Countryside: Responses to Rural Development in
the Almaguin Highlands
The
deregulation of global capital, or neoliberalism (Harvey 2006), has led to the
gentrification of portions of the Canadian countryside adjacent to large
cities, creating new opportunities for capital investment by transforming
working class spaces into residential and commercial zones (Smith 1998). It
recasts the countryside from a place of work to a place of leisure (White 1996)
as changing national priorities and international trade agreements make farming
and industry less profitable; simultaneously, recreation and tourism emerge as
development priorities. These changes generate tensions between tourists,
farmers, developers, new residents, and long-term residents over proper uses
and meanings of rural space. This shift from timber, mining and farming to
touristic and recreational consumption indicates a shift from ÔextractiveÕ to
ÔattractiveÕ models of development (Luke 2003). My fieldwork in the Almaguin
Highlands in Ontario explores these issues, where as a result of a highway
development/bypassing project and a rapidly changing rural economy, the social
landscape is undergoing significant transformations. In response to these
transformations, residents in the Almaguin Highlands have adopted various
strategies to cope with the challenges they are facing in this new economy.
Jon Wagner,
Knox College, 3-8
Economics,
Narrative Cognition, and the Lower Paleolithic Revolution
Although
popular lore has pictured the invention of fire, the wheel, or writing as
pivotal innovations in the evolution of humanity, and paleoanthropologists have
emphasized the transformative role of toolmaking, culture or symbolic
expression, less attention has been given to the role of economics. This paper suggests that the replacement
of hand-to-mouth feeding by an economic system in which food acquisition,
distribution and consumption became discrete events, separable in space/time
and regulated not by appetite but by social norms, was a key transition that
has received surprisingly little attention in the literature. This transition in social behavior was
a necessary concomitant of the life history changes evident in the fossil
record of erectine hominids, and its role in the evolution of human behavior
and cognition is sufficiently profound to give it the status of a major
behavioral revolution.
Jonathan E.
Reyman (first paper),
Illinois State Museum, 1-1
Avoiding
Spiritual Danger: the Illinois State Museum and Kohanim Project
NAGPRA
alerted museum professionals to potential problems of personal danger such as
spiritual contamination from the presence of human remainsin a museum or other
institution. But it is not just Native Americans who must contend with this
issue. Kohanim, members of the Jewish priestly class, also must deal with it.
The Chicago Rabbinical Council has had an ongoing conversation with the
Illinois State Museum about human remains at the museumÕs facilities, and at
other museums and institutions within the state that might be visited by
Kohanim, including school children. The context of this conversation, the
limits of the prohibition, and the implications for Kohanim and Native
Americans, and possibly others, are discussed.
Jonathan E.
Reyman (second paper), Illinois
State Museum, 2-3
Pueblo Oral
Histories and The Feather Distribution Project
Native
American oral history is generally given equal empirical weight with scientific
evidence to determine legitimacy of NAGPRA repatriation claims. Oral history
certainly has value but not equivalent to scientific data. The Feather Distribution Project
provides wild turkey, macaw, and parrot feathers free-of-charge to all 31
Pueblo villages in New Mexico and Arizona, 8,000,000+ feathers to date. The
project is applied anthropology but is based on archaeological and ethnographic
data. Ancient Ancestral Pueblo peoples ritually sacrificed turkeys and buried
them with elaborate grave goods, sometimes greater in number and richer in
content than contemporary human burials.
Presentations to Pueblo villages about the project and the turkey
burials elicit surprise that such practices occurred, denial of knowledge about
them, but interest in them – one example of archaeological evidence
exceeding native oral histories in richness of detail and time depth. Further implications
of the archaeological record for Pueblo oral histories are discussed.
Joseph M.
O'Neal, St. Edward's University, 2-14
Back to the
Future: Saving the World One (Garden) Plot at a Time
This paper
presents an ethnography of permaculture practicioners in Austin, Texas.
Permaculture refers to sustainable gardening and farming, but it also provides
a blueprint for transforming society from overconsumption and waste to one
characterized by rationality, permanence, sound nutrition, locally produced
food, and opting out of the consumer culture by choosing a sustainable
lifestyle. Although permaculture writers and scientists often look to tribal
societies for inspiration, the anthropological literature actually provides few
extended studies of sustainability of subsistence activities. This study argues
that permaculture fits best into the paradigm of revitalization movement.
Joseph
Weiss, University of Chicago, 2-13
Rural
Migrations and Pan-Native Selves: Native Rural-Urban Migration and Identity in
Vancouver, B.C.
The urban
Native population of the city of Vancouver, British Columbia has grown over the
last half a century from 239 in 1951 to almost 50,000 in 1996, a trend mirrored
in most major Canadian cities. This demographic explosion can be attributed
primarily to a regular flow of Native peoples moving from rural reserve
territories to urban centers (Frideres and Gadacz 2005:159-164). In this paper
I interrogate the effect this essentially migratory process has on practices of
and claims to Nativeness in urban contexts. Does movement away from reserves
destabilize spatial associations between reserve territory, band affiliation,
and a sense of Native identity? What conditions of possibility for new forms of
Nativeness does this, and has this, long-term migration created? If, as Cole
Harris claims, reserves have been the locus of Native space in British Columbia
since the beginnings of colonization, bearing on every facet of First Nations
life in the province (Harris 2002:xxi), what sorts of claims to ÒNative spaceÓ
originate out of urban relocation? Focusing on VancouverÕs Downtown Eastside, I
offer an example in which the destabilization of Native spatial identity that
rural to urban migration creates has contributed to the emergence in the
Downtown Eastside of claims to a ÒPan-Native spaceÓ that organizes around a
sense of common Nativeness rather than territorial or band affiliation.
Julie
Fairbanks, The University of Akron, 2-1
Public,
Social, Civic? Artistic Engagements in the Northwest Caucasus
How do artists
see their roles in society? On whose behalf and to whom do they speak? For
whose benefit and to what ends do they work? Based on fieldwork in the
northwest Caucasus region of southern Russia, this paper explores the
perceptions of local artists regarding their roles in society. On one hand,
artists in Russia work on behalf of citizens and society, promoting communal
revitalization, inter-communal dialogue or their own and their colleaguesÕ
professional development. On the other hand, they also work in the name of the
state. In fact, the line between these categories is often indistinct, as
artists and writers maintain connections to other members of their communities
and to the government as they create, perform and organize. Their situation is
at once shared with artists in other parts of the world and uniquely shaped by
the legacies of the Soviet Union, where social and public were often synonymous
and the state was the primary sponsor of creative production. In the context of
ideological and economic shifts in Russia, the paper examines the ways artists
and writers are finding their places in the new milieu.
Junjie
Chen, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2-6
Performing
the Family Planning Project in Post-socialist China: State Productions, Village
perceptio
Based on
fieldwork in and around a village in northeastern China, this paper explores
how villagersÕ reproductive experiences have been entangled with ongoing
processes of globalization and state transformations in post-socialist China. Over the past quarter-century, China
has been notorious for its stringent birth policy. However, around the turn of the new millennium, the Chinese
state became preoccupied with constructing an internationally acceptable image
of modernity and has attempted to soften the image of its strict population
policy as part of this broader effort.
As a significant component of the nation's eager participation in the
capitalist world economy, the government recently revised its national birth
control policy—to provide rural women (the state claimed) with more
"high-quality services" for their reproductive health. With this policy adjustment, the
Chinese state hopes that rural citizens will become receptive to a more
"scientific and progressive notion of childbearing," thereby
producing ÒcivilizedÓ rural subjects who nevertheless remain willing to accept
state-imposed birth control measures.
This paper examines the ways in which the local government showcased its
ÒhumaneÓ family planning project in a public event in summer 2005, and explores
how villagers interpret such presentation as Òsheer performanceÓ and respond to
the stateÕs recent birth policy through their actual reproductive
practices. In so doing, this paper
provides a case study of how global forces and state transformations are
intertwined in complicated ways to control the human body by regulating
reproduction.
Kaitlin
Korbitz, University of Northern Iowa, 3-7
Body,
Identity and Enculturation within the Tattoo Art Community
The
emergence of body modification-specifically tattoo art and piercing- as a form
of social deviance has transformed into a current cultural phenomena in the
past decade. An ancient ritual, tattoo art and body piercing has symbolic as
well as social significance and value in many cultures ranging from African
signs of fertility and maturity to signifying Japanese criminals. Entrenched in
symbolic significance and reflections personal as well as societal beliefs, the
practices of body modification have spiked and plummeted in popularity in the
United States. This study is designed to derive the social and personal
implications of body art in the Cedar Valley area as well as explore tattoo and
body piercing art forms in general. From understanding the weight of social
standards in a smaller community (Cedar Falls) one can juxtapose the formation
of identity and the effects of deviance of those practicing body modifications.
Kalimara
Otto-Gentry, Grinnell College, 2-9
"Have
You Seen Her?": Gendered Discourse and Agency in WNBA Game Commentary
This paper
explores the influence of WNBA sports commentary in framing how the television
audience both views and interprets the game of womens basketball and the womens
basketball player. This research builds on a study done by Vande Berg and
Projansky (2003) of the WNBA inaugural season in 1998 that compared WNBA games
to NBA games in terms of the types of narratives, or brief story lines, which
appear in the sports commentary. Ultimately, their study identified gendered
narratives that were specific to WNBA games. For my research, I drew upon the
list of narratives first identified by Vande Berg and Projansky (2003) and used
that modified list as the template for coding and analysis. The data analyzed
consisted of transcriptions of eight nationally televised WNBA games of the
2008 season. My findings indicate that despite progress from its beginnings,
almost 11 years later, gendered narratives in WNBA game commentary remain a
prevalent feature of sports commentary. The WNBA player is inaccurately framed
by the commentary as having a tiered identity, as a woman first and an athlete
second. These gendered narratives present the player in the televised game in
primarily nonathletic roles as heterosexual romantic partners and as mothers.
Karolyn
Last, Illinois State University, 3-15
ÒI DonÕt
KnowÓ By Itself Is Just Not Enough: Saving Face Through Obfuscation
In this
paper I argue that people from different walks of life have very
occupation-specific ways of linguistically expressing doubt or lack of knowledge.
In particular, I look at how one single notion—ÒI donÕt knowÓ—is
manifested by members of four different professions: physicians, journalists,
professors, and students. Data is presented from interviews with participants,
using situation-specific questions, as well as from observation. I show that
each group has their own ways of expressing this idea, usually without
specifically saying the actual phrase ÒI donÕt know.Ó I argue that obfuscation
occurs in most cases for at least two reasons: (1) speakers generally desire to
save face or pride, and (2) speakers in each of these roles are placed in a
position such that admission of lack of knowledge could have dire social or
professional consequences (e.g., a failing grade for a student, or a patientÕs loss
of confidence in a doctor). I relate this to general theories in
sociolinguistics, such as performance and politeness and speech act theory.
Kasia
Minor, College of Wooster, 3-7
The College
of Wooster's Students' Understanding of Organ Donation
This paper
is the result of my Independent Study rsearch with the student population at
The College of Wooster, a private liberal arts college in Ohio. My research explores whether or not
College of Wooster students believe in donating their organs and how this relates
to how these students view the world.
My results revealed important differences in their responses based on
race, ethnicity, and religious beliefs.
Overall, their responses reflect their perceptions of the role of a
responsible individual in the contemporary world.
Kate
Grim-Feinberg, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2-6
Rituals and
Staged Performances of Cow Branding in a Peruvian Agricultural Community
This
research addresses how children in an agricultural community in highland Peru
learn to position themselves within networks of power as they participate in
two annual events organized and mandated by local families, the community, and
the state. Early June cow branding rituals (herranzas) are rooted in
pre-Hispanic mountain cults, and coincide roughly with national Farmworker Day
(D’a del Campesino, June 24), in which children portray themselves as
farmworkers, performing the herranza along with other local customs and dances
in the town square. Through an analysis of video and audio recordings,
photographs, and ethnographic data from participant observation conducted in
rural Ayacucho, Peru in June 2008, this paper examines how people negotiate the
control and transmission of embodied knowledge in an indigenous agricultural
ritual and a staged representation of that ritual, and how these events teach
children to conceptualize their relationships with their families and
community; their animals, plants, and ÒguardianÓ mountains, and their nation.
Katerina
Friesen, Wheaton College, 2-17
ÒPrayer and
Feasting: Ritual Modification and Transformation among the Kalanguya-IkalahanÓ
The
Kalanguya-Ikalahan are an indigenous peopleÕs group from the mountains of
Northern Luzon, the Philippines. The Christians of the Kalanguya-Ikalahan
community in which I conducted my research are currently renegotiating the
rituals (baki) practiced by their traditionalist forefathers and mothers. This
paper explores two contrasting community responses to the now seldom-practiced
baki: Christian prayer services (gimong), and recently initiated modified
rituals. For the latter, I discuss attempts by aspiring tribal elders to
mobilize a cultural movement through the revival of pre-Christian traditional
ritual symbols and procedures. Apparent gaps and contradictions in these newly
modified rituals significantly alter earlier ceremonial meanings and purposes,
considered by the older elders as the essential elements of baki rituals.
Therefore, despite the aspiring eldersÕ purposeful adherence to and
preservation of ritual symbols and structures, the rituals they conduct fall
short of reproducing past ritual meanings. I propose that conversely, the
Christian prayer services maintain and generate cultural meanings significant
to the entire community. Though they do not utilize past forms, community
members consciously connect Christian prayer services to old and new meanings.
They see the services not simply as a replacement of ÒtraditionalÓ cultural
practices, but as a way of continuing, transforming, and redirecting their culture.
I thus argue that people create and maintain culture through their choices for
change, and that culture is defined more through these choices than by past
forms and practices.
Katherine
Lauth, Oberlin College, 3-6
Resistance
in the Hills: Intersections of Gender, Sense of Place, and Activism in Southern
West Virginia
The coal
industry has dominated West VirginiaÕs natural and cultural landscape for the
past 150 years. Since the development of the railway system, outside interests
have exploited the stateÕs land and people to gain control of the regionÕs rich
coal reserves. Technology has accelerated the process of extraction and
decreased the need for human labor, most recently with the practice of
mountaintop removal (MTR). Infiltrated water supplies and dust caused by
blasting have led to increased health problems for coalfield communities, and
the environmental damage is threatening the regionÕs subsistent way of life.
The majority of the population is directly or indirectly dependent on the coal
industry for income, making opposition uncommon. However, there are
environmental justice groups organizing against MTR, and the majority of the
activists involved are women. There are several reasons for this trend, ranging
from the practical to the political. WomenÕs social roles are more often
confined to the home, giving them more time to interact with community members
and organize. In addition, more women, and especially single women and widows,
are not reliant on the industry for their livelihood. Similar to womenÕs
participation in other environmental justice movements, many activists claim
that their roles as mothers and caretakers call them to activism. This paper
examines why women have organized in greater numbers than men, considering the
gendered social roles of Appalachia, womenÕs relations to the coal industry,
and senses of place.
Katherine
Wiley, Indiana University, 1-8
Transitioning
from Slavery to Citizenship: Negotiating Civil, Political, and Social Rights in
Mauritania
Slavery was
officially declared illegal in the Islamic Republic of Mauritania in 1980.
Since that time, although many groups have argued that remnants of this
institution persist, the Haratin (former slaves) have been negotiating their
civil, political, and social rights in the larger polity. When considering this
process, it is useful, therefore, to employ T. H. MarshallÕs (1998[1963])
rights-based model of citizenship; however, the Haratin example challenges some
of MarshallÕs premises, particularly his disregard for how factors including
race and ethnicity affect peopleÕs experiences of citizenship and his
implication that rights are gained in a particular order and a peaceful
fashion. Renato RosaldoÕs (1997) model of cultural citizenship is also a useful
tool in considering how Haratins supported their claims for rights; however,
their experience also challenges some of the premises of this model,
particularly its assumption of homogeneous ethnic groups. This paper, then,
will consider how the Haratin experience of claiming civil, political, and
social rights up through the 1980s not only complicated some elements of
MarshallÕs and RosaldoÕs models of citizenship, but also how it has contributed
to the redefinition of the meaning of full citizenship in Mauritania.
Kathleen C.
O'Brien, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 3-6
Gender and
the Politics of Evangelical Indigenous Religiosity in highland Ecuador:
Implications for Feminist Anthropology
My paper
utilizes preliminary field research to explore the ambiguous relationship
between feminism and global Christianity (and the narratives of modernity they
each entail) in the context of a multi-generational indigenous evangelical
movement in highlands Ecuador. I posit that the efforts of some local leaders
of the second generation of converts to re-interpret the Bible and missionary
doctrine to square both idealized indigenous and Christian gender relations
with Western feminist ideas of Ògender equalityÓ point to the emergence of a
particular kind of indigenous feminism not adequately addressed by either
feminist anthropology or the anthropology of Christianity. By Òindigenous
feminismÓ in this case I refer to an ÒundergroundÓ kind of feminism wherein
women who may not self-identify as feminist further a critique of male
domination informed by indigenous epistemologies as well as a deep commitment
to being good Christian subjects. I suggest that these challenges emerging from
within the unlikely space of evangelical Protestantism and the various
Òmodalities of agencyÓ they entail (see Mahmood 2005) offer important
interventions to feminist theory. They enable a further complicating of the
analytical category of feminism to account for the various manifestations and
challenges of indigenous Third World womenÕs activism and experiences.
Kathryn
Fay, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1-5
Collaborative
Communities and Boundary Dissolution in CyberSpace
Research at
the National Historic Site of New Philadelphia, Illinois, has gone far beyond
the typical practice of archaeology by attempting to become fully engaged with
the local and descendant communities. As a new phase in this initiative,
changes are being implemented to the project website in order to reorganize
currently published information and to provide a more accessible location for
forthcoming research results. This initiative is bringing the New Philadelphia
website into the Ònew worldÓ of interactive internet programs by creating a
more user-friendly and collaborative space for the exchange of information and
ideas. This increased accessibility will allow for greater personal
participation in this community-based project. This paper will present the
current stage of this project, as well as the proposed ideas of all those
collaborating, including archaeologists, historians, genealogists, descendants,
and local community members.
Katie
Szymanski, Illinois State University, 1-6
Certified
Organic: An Anthropological Study of the Organic Movement in Central Illinois
This paper
is a study of how organic certifications are affecting small organic farmers in
central Illinois, and asks whether organic codes and regulations benefit or
hinder them. The recent demand for safe Òcertified organicÓ food has led to an
increase in regulations on how food is made and distributed. However, this is a
complex process for consumers, producers, and regulators alike. For example,
what exactly makes food certifiably Òorganic,Ó and how does industrial
agriculture now affect what was once a relatively small niche of the
agricultural market? I examine such questions ethnographically by conducting
interviews with (1) small organic Illinois farmers, (2) consumers of locally
supplied food, (3) consumers of non-locally supplied food, and (4) private
certified organic organizations. I will also talk to participants and
organizers of local farmers markets. I argue that these previous local and
grassroots movements will now have to become more knowledgeable and aware of
global trends and markets to effectively compete in an increasingly competitive
ÒorganicÓ arena.
Katja
Pettinen, Purdue University, 1-3
Practices
of Thinking and Feeling
Various
concepts have been brought forth in social theory In order to address
limitations of a mind – body dichotomy, one of them being the term
embodiment. On a most general level, the term embodiment can be used to refer
to the overall presence of the body, and bodily knowledge in the realm of the
social. In this paper, I explore notions of embodiment, bodily knowledge, and a
semiotic notion of mindbody, in the context of such daily practices as
bicycling. I consider the use of bicycle as a form of transportation where
mindbody is a central instrument of movement. In such physical operations we
can consider how this movement is operated through bodily kinesthetic knowledge
- knowledge that is inherently embodied - not simply by superficial Òcognitive
decisions.Ó
Kay
Shelton, Northern Illinois University, 2-5
Social
Networking in Facebook: Sharing Comfort and Thoughts Following Tragedy
The ways in
which many college students interact are changing in the United States and
elsewhere. Through social networking Web sites such as Facebook, college
students can now communicate to 50,000 friends or more, all at the same time.
As people connect their social lives more through technology, college students
and others turned to social networking sites such as Facebook in times of
tragedy, to share messages of comfort and solidarity. Following one tragedy,
the leadership at one university considered tearing down the building where it
happened. Hundreds of students gathered on Facebook, organized, protested, and
presented a petition to the administration. The university then gathered
opinions in forums open to everyone on campus about the buildingÕs fate. One
student-run newspaper reporter lamented that only handfuls of students attended
the public forums yet over 5,000 students sent e-mail messages with their
opinions. Instead of images of students holding picket signs of the past, with
recent technologies, students participated in university activities without a
physical presence, yet affected the outcome. The university administration
reversed its decision about the building. This study will explore the use
Facebook by college students and others following campus shootings and terrorist
attacks. Lenses for the study include unobtrusive observation on publicly
available sections in Facebook with a theoretical framework based upon L. S.
VygotskyÕs Cultural-Historical Activity Theory (CHAT). Unfortunately, tragedies
are a part of the human experience and implications for college administrators
and other leaders will be explored.
Kellie J.
Hogue, Indiana University, 3-6
ÒShe is a
rough and wild creatureÓ: Narratives of Native Female Resistance in the Jesuit
Relations
While some
native women sought to receive instruction, baptism, and a new name from their
encounter with the Jesuit priests who visited them, a significant number of
native women actively resisted conversion. Labels such as Òproserpina,Ó
Òmegera,Ó Òwarrior woman,Ó Òtigress,Ó and Òshe-devil,Ó were applied to females
who found creative ways to avoid the influences of an imposed religion that
could sever the close bonds of a kin relationship with a husband, mother,
sister, or brother. One woman whose husband had converted and threatened to
leave her unless she received instruction was characterized as a Òrough and
wild creature.Ó What types of acts did native women engage in and how were
these acts interpreted as formal or informal resistance? What kinds of
strategies did native women utilize to promote and sustain the maintenance of
cultural values in the context of a contact experience that insisted upon the
erasure of native identity? What were the consequences of the acts and
strategies of resistance for native women? As part of a larger survey that
explores the experiences of native women recorded in the Jesuit Relations, this
paper draws upon anthropological theory and ethnohistorical methods to examine
accounts of native women attempted to reject Christianity.
Kevin Courtwright,
University of Central Missouri, 2-9
The legacy
of Roosevelt's Tree Army
"The
Legacy of a RooseveltÕs Tree Army" is a discussion of on-going
archaeological work on a Civilian Conservation Corps camp of the 1930s. The CCC
functioned as a means to provide work for unemployed men, and to preserve
natural resources, during the Great Depression. During the years that the CCC
camp near Warrensburg, Missouri, existed, it created hope for the future of
Johnson County, and remains today a vital though ignored artifact. Preliminary
investigations into the history and documentation of this camp reveal a complex
association between the camp and the surrounding community, and demonstrate the
importance of the site to local and regional history. Though initial information
about this camp was limited, through archival research and the collection of
historical documents, a clearer picture of the lives of the men in the camp
emerged. The researcher will also discuss plans for archaeological excavation
at the CCC camp site.
Kristen
Waymire, Wichita State University, 2-4
The
Dynamics of Gender Ideology of Hamas
The West
has often approached Hamas within an Orientalist perspective. As Said
established in his seminal work, Orientalism is a form of discourse that is
based on and maintained by the distinction made between Òthe OrientÓ or Òthe
OtherÓ and Òthe OccidentÓ (Said 1979: 2).
It is seen as monolithic and static. However, careful analysis reveals
that the movement is flexible and fluid. Hamas actually provides its own
discourse that offers an ever-changing framework of identity formation. By one
merely labeling the group as a "terrorist" organization, the
potential for comprehensive analysis is not only undermined but is reduced to
focusing on the groupÕs actions and doctrinal aspects of its charter. Although
some scholars have begun serious in-depth studies and research into the Islamic
Resistance Movement as a dynamic group within a broader context of
socio-economic and cultural factors influenced and generated by the Nakba and
subsequent Israeli occupation, the gender ideology of Hamas as well as other
Islamic movements has been greatly ignored. As Islah Jad, a Palestinian scholar
who is an associate professor at Bir Zeit University in the West Bank as well
as one of the founders of the Women Studies Institute at the university, states
in her article entitled "Between Religion and Secularism: Islamist Women
of Hamas" that not only has the gender ideology of Islamic movements been
sketchy but that also the women militants and their role(s) have been neglected
in the study of Islamic movements (Jad 2005:172).
Lance
Larkin, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2-2
The
Politics of the Burning Man Arts Festival: The Art of Performing a Gift Economy
The Burning
Man Arts Festival is an intense, experiential, annual celebration of art that
provides a blank slate where thousands of artists create unique and imaginative
artwork. Focusing more on the existentialism and experience of the viewer
rather than the permanence of the art, Burning Man is one of the largest
temporary collections of art in the world. This city-sized exhibition occurs in
the Black Rock Desert in Nevada for one week, where day temperatures reach 100+
degrees and dust storms often sweep across the large open space. Commercialism
is not allowed at the event so all materials for survival (food, water, living
accommodations, etc.) must be brought by participants. The harsh desert
environment combined with the communal sharing of artistic expression influences
people to think beyond materialism, encouraging the ÒgiftingÓ of their skills
and services to build community amongst strangers. The anti-commercial event
and the harsh environment pushes some participants to question capitalism and
the expected reciprocity of gift-giving beyond the boundaries of the event. As
a result, after Hurricane Katrina some participants returned – bringing
skills of living in inhospitable surroundings and an attitude of gift-giving
without the politics of reciprocity – to help people rebuild in New
Orleans. When examined as a rite of passage, the liminal performance of the
festival resulted in a space where Burning Man attendees questioned assumptions
that only bureaucratic organizations can help others. Re-incorporation to our consumer
society motivated them to roll up their sleeves and get to work.
Lanette
Mullins, Ivy Tech Community College, 3-15
The
Changing Face of American Educational Institutions
There has
been a growing trend among recent high school graduates and non-traditional
students to choose a community college rather than a traditional 4-year
institution. This growing trend has made Ivy Tech Community College of Indiana
(colleges are throughout the state) the largest college in the state of
Indiana, as well as the lowest tuition. Students can achieve an Associate
degree with transferable credits to most colleges in Indiana. The purpose of
this investigation/study was to examine this growth and why high school
graduates are moving toward faster technical degrees, rather than the longer
traditional 4-year degree. 100 Ivy Tech Community College, Northwest Region,
Valparaiso Campus students from Liberal Arts course were served to discern
demographic information: age, economic background, educational background, high
school GPA, career choice, and gender. Students were then asked focus questions
about why they chose a community college/technical college v. a traditional
4-year institution. All survey's were anonymous Preliminary research suggested
that recent high school graduates sought out Ivy Tech not only because of the
cost, but because with the technical degrees offered, students are in the
workforce much sooner, allowing them to achieve financial goals, rather than
slower traditional methods. Also, it allowed them to pursue an education while
in their current career or jobs. This trend of the last decade points to
economic changes and concerns for current high school graduates, but also a
change in interest - specifically that students are more interested in the career
and financial security that that career offers, rather than the
prestigeiousness of the institution from which such degrees would have been
traditionally received from. Further, this suggests that the traditional 4-year
institution may be less attractive to future high school graduates thus,
possibly setting a trend in a powerful movement to community colleges.
Laura
Blum-Smith, Oberlin College, 2-13
Nations and
Immigrants: Immigration in American and Canadian National Identities
Although
America and Canada have each been called a "nation of immigrants,"
this characterization is now contested by recent scholarship. Nonetheless,
"nation of immigrants" reveals something profound and complex about
American and Canadian history as well as their respective national
self-conceptions. Both countries have had complicated relationships to their
incoming foreign populations. A mix of pride and guilt has shaped the discourse
about current issues related to "racial," ethnic, cultural and
linguistic difference. This paper examines American and Canadian immigration
policy and discourse and compares the way the interplay between immigrants and
national identity has evolved over time. By doing so, it attempts to understand
some of the current tensions and debates about the way that the concepts of
"nation" and "belonging" are imagined in each country.
Laura
Yakas, Kenyon College, 3-16
The
Traditions of Holy Week and the Perceptions of the Community, in a rural
Honduran town
This
cultural anthropology field study was conducted from January to May 2008 in the
two rural towns of Pueblo Nuevo and Petoa, in Santa Barbara, Honduras. These
two towns are within ten minutes walk from one another. Petoa has been a
settlement since early pre-colonial times, whereas Pueblo Nuevo is a recently
developed town right off the highway that connects the two largest urban
centers in Honduras. Both Pueblo Nuevo and Petoa are mestizo, or communities of
integrated Spanish and indigenous decent, however Petoa, having a longer
history, has a population with very strong familial bonds and ties to the area.
Contrastingly, Pueblo Nuevo is newer, and the population more transient, and
less established. To gather information I employed snowball sampling,
unstructured, semi-structured, and structured interviews. The focus of this
research was the celebrations and traditions of Holy Week. There were conflicts
between two types of traditional celebrations that took place simultaneously,
those of the ÒchurchÓ and those of the ÒtownÓ - which local people informed me
were different. There were typical Catholic ceremonies and processions
undertaken by the delegates of the churches and devout Catholic community
members, and traditions that have supposed indigenous roots and involve dance,
costume, and the disorderly behavior. Through discussion with informants,
reasons for these conflicts were explored, and the purpose of this paper is to
convey the nature of the two conflicting traditions, as well as the opinions
and perceptions people have about them and the future of Holy Week.
Lauren
Anaya, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1-4
WhereÕs the
ÒProofÓ?: the Absence of "Evidence" as a Theoretical Construct in
Legal Anthropology
Conversations
about evidence are notably absent from legal anthropological projects that
focus on what happens in the courtroom. This is peculiar when one considers the
emphasis placed on evidence by legally-trained persons, especially in the
courtroom venue. Using published journal articles and books, I will investigate
theoretical claims regarding the concept of evidence proffered by legal
anthropologists. I will also interrogate various uses of evidence by legal
anthropologists who are doing work in the courtroom, with a specific emphasis
on the role played by evidence in the production of knowledge. I argue that
legal anthropologists need to give serious consideration to the concept of
evidence and reevaluate the role that evidence plays in their own work. By
engaging with evidence, legal anthropologists will be better able to communicate
with law-makers, judges, lawyers, and other legally-trained persons. Such
communication is necessary if we want our work to be read.
Lauren E
Miller, Indiana University, 2-1
Volunteerism
and Capoeira
Having
arisen out of African martial, musical, and dance traditions and taking root in
the fertile soil of Brazil«s senzalas (slave quarters), the Afro-Brazilian
martial art capoeira has today become an international phenomenon. The art
attracts a diverse group of practitioners with respect to age, religion, race
and nationality. However, a certain subset of this population is taking their
participation to extremes. They are not only learning the traditional language
of capoeira, Portuguese, but going on pilgrimages to Brazil for upwards of a
year or more. This work takes as its focus the negotiation of legitimacy
between local and foreign capoeiristas in its traditional home, Salvador da
Bahia, Brazil. Bourdieu has shown that legitimacy is achieved within social
fields based on an individual«s propensity to act in accord with preset
standards. In this line of reasoning, legitimacy in capoeira would be confered
to those individuals who most closely adhered to the proper form. However, in
practice, other characteristics are far more important within the capoeira
community. According to both foreign and local capoeiristas, charismatic
factors trump skill and form. And while these two groups agreed on the
importance of most charismatic factors, interviews with 25 capoeiristas
revealed one glaring and unexpected exception. Brazilians and foreigners
differed significantly in their feelings about the importance of doing
volunteer work in Brazil, which is the primary focus of this paper.
Laurie
Rush, US Army, 2-7
Archaeologists
Working with the Military
During the early
years of the US invasion of Iraq, the US Military was criticized in the global
press for damaging Mesopotamian archaeological sites like Babylon. In order to
prevent further damage, deploying personnel need to be educated about these
properties. The only people qualified to provide this information are
archaeologists, many of whom trained originally as anthropologists. In
September of 2008, the Senate ratified the Hague Convention for the Protection
of Cultural Property during Times of Armed Conflict. This treaty law further
obligates the Department of Defense to minimize damage to archaeological sites
within their areas of responsibility anywhere in the world. Cooperation between
archaeologists and the military is critical if we are to meet these goals, and
the potential benefits, not just for host nation citizens but for the global
community, will far outlast the times of conflict.
Leslie
Cofie, Case Western Reserve University, 2-13
The Health
Phenomenon of Black Immigrants in the US
Research
findings have consistently demonstrated that racial/ethnic minority groups,
particularly African-American, in the U.S. have poorer health outcomes in
comparison to white American groups. Moreover, existing evidence reveals that
black immigrants have better health status than U.S.-born blacks. Proposed
explanations for why black immigrants have better health status than
African-Americans include (1) immigrant selectivity hypothesis, (2) the context
of immigration, and (3) identity formation. However, these justifications offer
incomplete understanding of the unique characteristics of black immigrants that
help generate the higher health status within this population, compared to
African-Americans and other subsequent generations of black immigrants in the
U.S. A structural-constructivist approach is used to explore alternate
explanations that will further expound the reasons for the superior health
status experienced by black immigrants. This paper suggests that protective
factors shielding black immigrants from negative health outcomes are shaped by
the constrains of their current social structure. Further research is needed to
determine why these protective factors have either deteriorated or disappeared
in later generations of black immigrants.
Linda L.
Giles and Monica Udvardy, Illinois Wesleyan University, 2-12
Doing the
Right Thing: Museums, Mijikenda Ancestor Statues, and Repatriation--A Case
Study
This paper
will examine the roles of museums in acquiring, exhibiting, and repatriating
Kenyan Mijikenda memorial statues (vigango). We examine how American museums
acquired vigango (which are usually stolen from Mijikenda families). We then
discuss the reactions of museum personnel when confronted with evidence of
vigango theft, including that of two musuems which were asked to repatriate two
stolen vigango whose Mijikenda owner was documented. The evolving role of the
National Museums of Kenya in requesting and implementing this repatriation,
including providing assistance to the victimized family, will also be examined.
Lastly, we will discuss the reactions of other American museums to this
repatriation, including voluntary offers to repatriate vigango in the promotion
of social justice.
Lisa
Bintrim, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 1-2
We're From
the West, and We're Here to Help: Discourse in Volunteer Narratives
International
volunteers are one of the most visible and enduring forms of foreign
development assistance in Africa. Yet both the concept of international
volunteering and the volunteer experience are largely absent in the
anthropology of development. Anthropologists have yet to grapple with
Òinternational volunteerÓ as a social and discursive category as they have done
with such related categories as Òdevelopment workerÓ and Òtourist.Ó Preliminary
research on volunteering in Malawi, however, suggests that the international
volunteer is a problematic category. Local community members and Western
volunteers may have competing constructions of the volunteer identity,
including what the criteria are for being a volunteer (as opposed to another
category of foreigner) and what discursive meanings are attached to
international volunteers. In this paper, I will explore Òinternational
volunteerÓ as a discursive category by examining how the volunteers construct
their identities and experiences in narratives. Through an analysis of
published narratives from Western volunteers, I will demonstrate how these
narratives employ discourses of morality, Africa, and development. Moreover, I
will argue that the discourse and rhetoric of volunteer narratives closely
reflect that of pre- and postcolonial missionaries. Thus, I will suggest a link
between Western constructions of the international volunteer and the historical
Western hegemony in African development.
Mackenzie
Loyet, Knox College, 1-1
The Maasai
Interpretations of the Laetoli Footprints and the Effects of Future Tourism
Development in Laetoli, Tanzania
Many
historically significant sites throughout Tanzania are currently being
threatened by a number of elements: natural erosion, climate fluctuations,
vandalism, and simple neglect. In an effort to improve the cultural heritage
management and conservation of the Laetoli footprints, the Antiquities Division
of Tanzania has proposed the development of a new, on-site museum and research
center. In this project, a series of interviews was conducted with Maasai
individuals living around the Laetoli area to investigate the positive and
negative effects of the future museum. It was found that while a new museum
will bring more visitors and income to the region, it will also force many
Maasai to move away. Opinions were mixed over this conflict, with roughly half
the interviewees excited for the development and half displeased to leave the
area. Overall, this Laetoli problem reflects a greater conflict between Maasai
communities and the Ngorongoro Conservation Area Authority.
Mary
Benedetto, The University of Akron, 2-1
Como
Caracoles; Barcelona Street Artists Leave Their Trail
In this
paper I will be addressing how the laws governing and prosecuting the placement
of art in public spaces in Barcelona, Spain have historically affected and are
still affecting street artists, their works, and the once-legendary community
of art makers in Barcelona. Having recently interviewed a small but important
number of the most prominent street artists still living in Barcelona I have a
deepening understanding of how the political and cultural milieu of Barcelona
is imprinting itself into the larger notion of what it means to be an
urban-based artist circa 2008. Some of the main topics I will be addressing
include why street artists are still choosing to do art in Barcelona despite
toughening laws and what should be allowable in public space. Given the visual
specificity of my ethnographic research, I plan to weave in insights from the
field of visual anthropology, as well.
Meghan
Sarah Harrison, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, 1-8
Seeing the
light in CSI: co-construction in law, science, and society
Based on my
field research in a county courthouse, this paper focuses on interactions
thought to be influenced by the CSI effect. The CSI effect can be described as
conflict derived from inaccuracies between media portrayals and real-time
procedures. In particular, the CSI effect plays a large role in discussions of
evidence which require laboratory analysis, like DNA. While the CSI effect is
commonly described in negative terms, this research demonstrates its presence
also plays an important role in adapting court house proceedings to shifting
social perceptions of legal procedure. Because of this, conflicts caused by the
CSI effect can be interpreted as a positive sign. Such contention marks the
ability for county courthouses to reflect concerns and meanings created in the
daily life which exists outside of courtrooms. The shifting interpretations of
evidence, miscommunications, and arguments surrounding the CSI effect are
invaluable for understanding how law, science, and society are engaged. For DNA
evidence, the CSI effect demonstrates how people actively engage differences in
knowledge to provide their personal positions with greater power.
Melinda
Bernardo, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1-4
Who's a
Jew? Standards of Evidence and The Jewish Agency for Israel
Who is a
Jew? While it is an age-old question, it is one that continues to drive heated
debate. This paper is an effort to challenge the seeming naturalness of the
category of Jewish, one which is frequently relied upon by the Jewish Agency
for Israel, known in Hebrew, the Sochnut. In this paper I will evaluate the
Agency's standards of evidence for Jewishness in relation to its decisions
about the allocation of programming resources for its Zionist education and
immigration information projects. I will argue that despite the Agency's
seeming concern with Jewishness, its primary interests lay elsewhere.
Melony
Stambaugh, Northern Kentucky University, 2-5
Connecting
the Dots: Interlocks Creating Networks in Social Services
Social
Networks in Non-profit organizations are formed through the interlocking of key
members of the organization. Through these interlocks or connections, a network
is formed linking the organizations to each other and creating the means to
create bases of power, move money, and collaborate on projects. This paper
shows examples of how a network can be structured and diagrammed.
Meredith L.
Johnson, Indiana University, 2-17
Embodied
Revitalization: Dance, Performance, and Cultural Revivalization in the
Chickasaw Nation
American
Indian cultural revitalization movements, like all cultural movements, work to
create, maintain and negotiate notions of individual and group identity. These
notions of Òus-nessÓ are intensely tied to the ways the past, and the
activities from which the past is evoked, are engaged. As one of 23 woodland
groups residing in Oklahoma, the Chickasaw have actively and self-consciously
engaged with the preservation and revitalization of cultural traditions in
order to make cultural knowledge meaningful for every Chickasaw. Current cultural
revitalization efforts focus on a variety of activities including language
acquisition, sports activities, art and craft classes, and stomp and social
dances. As an ongoing traditional cultural practice in many woodland
communities Stomp and Social Dances are heavily imbued with individual and
group identity. As a physical activity specific to woodland cultures it offers
an opportunity to examine the link between revitalization and the body. For the
Chickasaw, who maintain non-ceremonial public stomp and social dance grounds on
tribally owned land, the preservation and performance of these dance forms is
open to every tribal member. Currently, the Chickasaw not only organize monthly
stomp dance activities on tribal land but also maintain a social dance performance
troupe, the Chickasaw Dance troupe. This paper focuses on the range,
limitations, and negotiations of Chickasaw Stomp and Social Dance
revitalization by examining the bodily discourse of individual participants and
how the very act of participating in this group cultural practice transforms a
physical sense of Chickasaw-ness to a group sense of cultural continuity.
Michael
Ryan, Binghamton University, 1-8
From pueblo
street fighting to martial art;
To know how
to fight with the machete, knife and the walking stick was a necessary part of
Venezuelan male socialization up until the 1950Õs when the use of this type of
knowledge declined. Recent government sponsored promotion of local culture as
part of an oppositional modernity to North American hegemony, has meant these
once marginalized practices are now undergoing a renewed popularity. However,
the ideologies and practices of these arts that treat the world as a hostile
place, and the necessity of keeping ones knowledge of the art secret still shapes
the practice and transmission of the art today. Drawing on a state sponsored
workshop of local stick fighting methods foregrounds a process where the
ideologies and perceptual schemas of looking at and acting in the world are
shaped through physical training. Describing how local forms of stick fighting
are taught as a martial art, I want to foreground how such concepts as the
teacher –student relationship, keeping a 'closed habitus' or developing
an attitude of Ôtrading a blow for a blowÕ are marginalized in favor of mass
drills, invented rituals and diluted techniques geared towards producing a
healthy body and loyal citizen.
Michael
Todd Gross, Western Michigan University, 2-10
Obstetric
Fistula: An Evolutionary and Biocultural View
Obstetric
fistula is a maternal health condition that occurs at alarming levels in
Nigeria. Indeed, one million females may be affected there (one in sixty
women). Obstetric fistula is ultimately a product of the unique evolutionary
history of the human species. The evolution of bipedal locomotion necessitated
a narrow pelvis, while the evolution of a large brain resulted in
encephalization. Consequently the human species is unique among the higher
primates in experiencing a high rate of obstructed labor due to disproportion between
the maternal pelvis and the fetal head. During obstructed labor involuntary
uterine contractions continue, applying pressure between the fetal head, the
soft tissues of the pelvis (i.e. the vagina, rectum, and bladder), and the
motherÕs pelvic bone. With the blood supply cut off, these tissues undergo
necroses, and within days a vesicovaginal fistula (VVF) or rectovaginal fistula
(RVF) has formed. Women with VVF or RVF continually and uncontrollably leak
urine or feces down their legs and onto their clothes. As a result of the
offensive odor they often face severe social ostracism, with the remainder of
their life course being dramatically altered. Fistula occurs at a distinct
intersection between ultimate and proximate biological forces and local cultural
beliefs and practices. The widespread practice of early childhood marriage,
purdah (wife seclusion), kunya (modesty or shame that surrounds childbirth),
poor nutrition, endemic diseases, a crumbling Nigerian health care system, and
the unique evolutionary course of the human species all contribute to the
prevalence of this appalling condition in Nigeria.
Monica Santos, University of Illinois at
Urbana-Champaign, 1-4
Examining
Evidence in the Anthropology of Performing Arts
This paper
discusses the use of ÒevidenceÓ in the Anthropology of Performing Arts. It
takes off from Anya Peterson RoyceÕs discussion on an anthropological approach
to the study of the performing arts. In her book, The Anthropology of
Performing Arts: Artistry, Virtuosity, and Interpretation in a Cross-Cultural
Perspective (2004), Royce seems to favour the use of biographical accounts and
interviews with individual performance artists in the fields of dance, music
and mime, as well as descriptions of healing rituals, to elaborate on and
understand cultural constructions of concepts such as (but are not limited to)
aesthetics, virtuosity and artistry. This paper examines this evidence in terms
of the authority it seems to draw from, as well as the implications of the use
of such evidence in doing cultural anthropology.
Muhammed
Bilal Kenasari, Wichita State University, 2-4
Social
Tension and Fear in Turkey: Exemplified by Imam Hatip Schools
Imam
Hatip Schools originated during the first Turkish parliamentÕs reign. They are
founded to teach religion as well as other subjects (mathematics, science,
philosophy, foreign language etc.) all together in one school (Aksit 1991, Pak
2004). This, in turn, raised parallel to the Turkish urbanization. It changed
rural conservativeness to urban conservativeness. I will argue that the Imam
Hatip schools are the best example in producing modern Islam. However, Turkish
secularists claim that they are the biggest threat for Turkish laicism, and
they build a block against Turkish modernism. In my paper I will propose that
this form of modernism raised through the Imam Hatip Schools goes beyond the
horizon of these Turkish secularists who think only in binary confrontational
terms and polemics. Based on my own experiences with Imam Hatip Schools I will provide
some ethnographic insights in the working and organization of this educational
institution.
Myrdene
Anderson (first paper), Purdue University, 1-3
Making
Sense of Senseprints
The
emergence of our species left traces including literal and figurative
footprints from 3 1/2 million years ago and handprints from 30,000 years
ago. Beyond touch and sight, other
senses configure the relationships between the human creature and its natural
and cultural matrix. Language and
culture enumerate the senses, among which language itself may be overlooked for
its transparency. Other evidence
elaborates the mutual mindprints between our lineage and its Umwelt
inferred from various modeling systems. Contemporary discourse relies on metaphors
informing
our understanding of ourselves-cum-Umwelt, 'footprint' paramount among
them. Indeed, the popular
reference
'ecological' or 'carbon' footprint indexes the habits of
hands, minds, and money, not feet,
and may have reached a saturation
point regarding its capacity to nuance
signification.
Myrdene
Anderson Purdue University, and Devika Chawla, Ohio University, 1-7
Paths Not
Taken, Cascades Aborted, and the Residual Life
The
coauthors have collaborated for several years on a project braiding
biography, autobiography, ethnography, and autoethnography.
Specifically, Anderson and Chawla,
inspired by
Gregory Bateson, have
indulged themselves in
analyzing their mutual metalogues and other texts
written by themselves
and others,
whereby the younger scholar might probe the life of the
elder scholar,
and to some extent, vice-versa. In the resulting open Rorschach of a
life and lives,
the role of memory, the issues of
disclosure, and the
compulsion
to make sense, all conspire to problematize the project
itself. In this paper, we ruminate and posit
that
any life narrative will be riddled
with absences that,
through markedness, might be foregrounded as
presences. Insofar as one can bring into consciousness
any paths not
taken, any deflection from a compelling process, or any
editing of voice
not just for rhetorical purposes, but primarily for
comprehension—these
elasticities fuse absences and presences. Consequently, an infinitude of
Peircean possibilities, probabilities, and actualities compete for
articulation in a finite space-time.
Nataliya
Semchynska-Uhl, Purdue Univesity, 1-3
Perspectives
of Absence: Suggestive
Representations of Virual Presence
Sometimes
the absence of something (or somebody) can be as significant as its presence or
may be even more noteworthy. The absence of something that should be present in
the complete picture manifests stronger actualization of the absent
object/subject in our minds. The absence of certain symptoms may help to
diagnose a patient. The beep instead of a profanity word does not make it
disappear from the context. A bag on a theatre seat or a jacket on a cubicle
chair represents the virtual presence of a physically absent person. The choice
of the objects which can function as such representations is culturally appointed
and depend on certain traditions. There are some cross-cultural as well as
ethnic specific objects which can be used in the representative function.
Footprints and traces epitomize a type of representative objects. Humans are
able to reconstruct the event flow decoding footprints.
Natasha
Kipp, University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign, 2-2
Eurasia and
the 2008 Eurovision Song Contest
The
Eurovision Song Contest is a most paradoxical performance competition. Despite its name, the contest is not about
music. It is about music as a
popular-based political tool for visibility and acceptance within the more
powerful unit of "Europe".
Included for the first time in this competition was Azerbaijan, making
2008 the first year to feature all three newly independent republics of the
South Caucasus-Azerbaijan, Armenia and Georgia. While each country only represents itself, the relations
between them acnnot be ignored and are often revealed, at least through the
voting process. Due to serious
territorial issues in Eurasia, I hypothesize that it is informative to analyze
the three 2008 entries of the South Caucasus individually, and more
importantly, as a unit. While we
can see the choices and hear the statements of their government officials,
Eurovision offers a glimpse into the feelings of its performers and voting
public.
Nicholas
Timmons, Kansas State University, 2-9
Afaan
Oromoo Proverbs: Patterns Creating Worldview
Afaan
Oromoo proverbs contain a bipartite poetic structure which makes them resilient
storehouses for cultural information. This paper will trace how the poetic
structural patterns of Afan Oromoo proverbs serve to create and recreate a
worldview within Afaan Oromoo culture. It will use proverbs collected by both
myself and Enrico Cerulli and will draw from three main works: The principles
of meaning introduced by Donatus Nwoga to view Afan Oromoo Proverbs in a
cultural context, the poetic analysis of Hausa proverbs by Tae-sang Jang to
analyze their poetic structure, and the interactional theories used by Joyce
Penfield, Mary Duru, and Frank Salamone to show how Afan Oromoo proverbs are
used to perpetuate and manipulate behaviors and core values. This paper
supports the hypothesis, proposed by Edward Sapir, that language shapes
worldview. It suggests that a catalyst of this process is the poetic structures
that create memorable phrases which are spoken frequently and passed on through
generations.
Nilda
Vargas, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1-4
Evidence of
Human Rights Violations in Colombia
In recent
years, non-governmental organizations (NGOs) have expressed alarm about human
rights violations against indigenous and afro-descendant communities in
Colombia. These rural communities were forcibly displaced near the rain forest
and the Arturo River on the Pacific Coast in the department of Choc—. The
communities' narratives are evidence of how their culture has been affected by
becoming an internally displaced population(IDP). This paper addresses why land
and territory displacement is a violation of human rights, and how forced land
displacement disrupts the ability of these communities to nurture their
relationships as a community. This paper will examine how land and territory
are significant in these individuals lives.
Nina Corazzo,
Valparaiso University, 2-1
Public
Eyesores: Displacements by Tadashi Kawamata
Japanese-born
installation artist Tadashi Kawamata has become notorious internationally for
his messy architectural accretions superimposed on various urban landscapes. He
takes detritus like unfinished lumber, found objects, and scraps of metal from
construction sites and crafts messy, higgelty-piggelty, flimsy squats in trees
or onto buildings chosen for their cultural, historical, sociological, and/or
sociological significance. This paper will explore how these unsightly works
address urban poverty through their juxtaposition with public sites signifying
privilege and power.
Pauline
Spiegel, Indiana University, 1-7
Discovering
the State in the Footsteps of Opposition: Participation and De-Legitimation in
a Controv
During the
conflict over the installation of a new Interstate in Southwest Indiana, the
responsible government agency, the Indiana Department of Transportation,
deployed its resources to generate the ideal of the state as a corporate,
unified, and unassailable whole to represent a Òstate ideaÓ (Mitchell 1991,
Abrams 1988 [1977]). Protestors, however, fought back. In this paper I argue
that there is no better way to track INDOTÕs state-making efforts than to
follow the objections of the highway opponents whom I was observing. Opponents
perpetually engaged in trying to discredit INDOTÕs process as it prepared the
last and final environmental research report. Thus, while the government worked
to construct the route in a manner that would support its own legitimacy, at
the same time the opponents of the route attacked the legitimacy of the
governmentÕs position wherever they could. I follow the actions of opponents of
new Interstate 69 (I-69) as they found and exploited cracks in state discourse.
Activists argued that the Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT)Õs images
and statements about the highway were simply wrong on a number of counts. When
highway opponents pointed out where individual interests were personal, funds
had been misused, or facts distorted, they were disrupting the boundary that
the state maintained between its own interests and those of constituents.
Activist statements disassembled and pointedly took apart the ambiguously
encompassing entity that the state made for itself.
Phyllis
Passariello, Centre College, 1-7
Our 'Other'
Ourselves: Corpses and Alloanimals
Cross-culturally,
the human corpse presents the living with a Ôbrute factÕ requiring action.
Dealing with the corpse activates dynamic behaviors between humans and their
environment, which includes alloanimals, thus potentially leading into
transspecies ideologies and interactions. These beliefs and behaviors can be
part of the process toward meaningful resolution or at least mediation of the
universal demands of mortality. Perhaps being human necessitates a Ôbio-moralÕ
attitude toward human remains. And, in some cultures, building walls against
mortality includes as well a biomoral transference to alloanimals and even to
their remains. In a parallel realm, this transference elicits special beliefs
and behaviors regarding our alloanimal Ôshadow selves.Õ This paper is a
cross-cultural, ethnographic look at ancient and contemporary mortuary ritual,
as well as related issues of animism, totemism and other transspecies
connections, with specific reference to cultures of the Amazon Basin.
Rebecca
Chan, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2-12
From
Pre-Contact to Present: Graffiti Mitigation at Bandelier National Monument
Graffiti
mitigation within AmericaÕs National Parks raises various ethical dilemmas
revolving around question of ÔWhat to preserve and for whom?Õ. By tracing the
development of cultural resource management in the United States, specifically
focusing on the National Park Service, this paper argues that graffiti
mitigation at Bandelier National Monument reflects visitorsÕ expectations
regarding the ÒauthenticÓ National Park experience. Rather than creating a
contrived, theme park-like environment, the author argues that Bandelier should
be thought of as a palimpsest of a history of occupation and management
reflecting cultural and social expectations and values from the pre-contact era
to present. Therefore, in order to justify its practices, it is vital for the
Park Service to incorporate this concept into BandelierÕs public interpretative
programs and literature. These are issues that are not only relevant to the
management of Bandelier National Monument, but are concerns that must be
addressed from a theoretical and practical platform throughout the realm of
cultural resource preservation and management.
Rick
Feinberg, Kent State University, 3-8
Radial
Frames of Reference in Polynesia:
Taumako Systems of Spatial Orientation
Bennardo
(2002) has argued for the dominance of a radial frame of reference in Tonga,
one of the island groups where Polynesian languages and cultures first
emerged. He makes his case by
calling upon several lines of evidence: linguistic, psychological, and ethnographic. Although his conclusions for the most
part seem compelling, he acknowledges the preliminary nature of his findings
and calls for comparable studies elsewhere in Polynesia. This essay is conceived as a response
to BennardoÕs call—it aims to elucidate the construction,
conceptualization, and representation of space on Taumako, a
Polynesian-speaking community in the eastern Solomon Islands. I argue that the Taumako embrace
several distinct but overlapping systems for talking and thinking about space,
and that the particular system employed in any instance is contextually
driven. While concurring with
Bennardo that Taumako systems of spatial representation are largely radial in
orientation, however, I have reservations about calling their frame of reference
Òabsolute.Ó
Ripan
Malhi, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2-3
Genetic and
Cultural Identities
Recent
advances in molecular genetic technology have made it possible to assess the
biological ancestry of individuals and populations. This technology has
promoted the development of ÒBiogeographic AncestryÓ tests by companies and has
sparked debate in the academic community. The implications of these tests and
technology will be discussed.
Robert R.
Sands, Air Force Culture and Language Center, 2-7
Introduction
to Culture, an Air Force Perspective
In March
2009, the Air Force will launch a first of a kind Distance Learning
Introduction to Culture course to eligible enlisted Airmen. Hosted by the
Community College of the Air Force and Air University, the course will be
accessible to Airmen stationed anywhere in the world and will provide the
foundational course in the development of cross-cultural competency in the Air
Force. The concept of designing an introduction to culture course for a
military population offers a unique opportunity to marry the theoretical (and
culture general concepts) with a uniquely derived applied perspective of Airmen
to promote a cultural competency that can immediately benefit a deeper and more
meaningful awareness and sensitivity to foreign cultures. This paper will
explore the concept of culture as it is presented in this course and how it
initiates the development of cross-cultural competency.
Robin
Konscak, College of Wooster, 2-17
Modernity,
Tradition, and Rights: A conflict of the ages as viewed through Xhosa ritual
circumcision
My paper
focuses on the influence of modern globalization on traditional indigenous
rituals and the tensions or conflict that results. Specifically I am looking at
the ritual of ukweta. Ukweta is a circumcision ritual for amaXhosa males in
South Africa aged 15 to 25 and is designed to prepare them for adulthood as
well as unify and strengthen Xhosa identity. It involves seclusion with other
initiates at a circumcision school, a local Xhosa surgeon, and no anesthetics.
Traditionally, it is taboo for circumcised men to share anything about the
ritual with those who are not circumcised. However, anthropologists have been
able to gather sufficient information about the makeup of the ritual despite it
being forbidden. Because I am concerned with the effects of globalization
rather then the specifics of the ritual itself, my key interests are gathering
first hand information that lends itself to the larger discussion of indigenous
rights in a global society. Having had the opportunity to interview Xhosa men
who have undergone ukweta, my paper provides a thorough, first-hand
understanding of the complexities facing indigenous tradition in a modern
world.
Rowan
Steineker, Westminster College, 3-16
Social
Relationships and Interactions Among the Residents of the ÒPresbyterian ManorÓ
Closed
communities in which members have almost constant social contact with each
other but limited social contact with outsiders, produce unconventional
constructions of social relationships. This study examines the basic social
interactions and relationships within the closed community of a nursing home
facility. In particular, the focus is on how differentiated care-levels form
basic social structures among residents and limiting the interactions between
them. Despite these divisions the residents construct social relationships such
as friendship very broadly and inclusively although their extensive social
contact causes the expression of these relationships to be characterized more
by physical togetherness than verbal communication. The research yielded in
this study is based on a three-month field research project in which a variety
of methodologies including participant observation, interviews, and surveys
were used to collect data.
Rupal
Satra, University of Illinois at Chicago, 2-10
The Space
Around Sickle Cell Disease
Sickle Cell
Disease (SDC) is a genetic blood disorder that is characterized by abnormally
shaped red blood cells that loses their plasticity and overall ability to
perform proper physiological processes. Subsequently, there are various health
related issues that arise from early childhood that incur social, economic, and
cultural implications. SCD is predominantly found in people, or descendants,
from tropical regions where malaria was common such as South Asia and Africa.
In the US, it has been estimated that 1,000 children are born each year with
sickle cell disease, in which one in twelve African-Americans has sickle cell
trait. Although there are have been many advancements in treating SCD symptoms,
researchers have yet to discover a cure. As a result, children regularly endure
visits to clinics, hospitals, and emergency rooms where they consistently
interact with health care professionals to receive treatment. The following are
narrative accounts given by pediatric sickle cell patients describing the
physical space of a sickle cell clinic. From these reports, we can extrapolate
and analyze patterns that elucidate their experiences living with SCD such as
socio-economic effects, treatment perceptions, and practitioner-patient
relationships.
Ruth
Gomberg-Mu–oz, University of Illinois at Chicago, 3-13
Transnational
Labor, Local Strategies: Immigrant Busboys in Chicago
In spite of
the evidence that Mexican immigrants in the United States have an iconic image
as Òhard workersÓ with Ògood attitudes,Ó the ways in which immigrant workers
themselves reproduce and resist this image remains under-examined. Based on a
year-long ethnographic study, my paper provides a micro-level look at how a
group of immigrant busboys cultivate an image of themselves as Òthe best
workers we haveÓ at a Chicago-area restaurant. By promoting norms of hard work,
willingness to work, teamwork, reciprocity, and flexibility, these workers
struggle to attain a measure of financial security and social esteem in spite
of their status as illegal immigrants. This paper focuses on the agency of
undocumented workers as they combat economic uncertainty, nurture dignity and
self-esteem, and cultivate and help sustain markets for their labor.
Sarah
Baird, Centre College, 2-13
From
Mineshaft to Mountaintop: Exploring Appalachian Folk Medicine
An
examination of Appalachian folk medicine from a native anthropologist
perspective, From Mineshaft to Mountaintop: Exploring Appalachian Folk Medicine
delves into the inner-workings of modern day folk medicine practices and
practitioners, the intersection of folk medicine with 21st Century modern
medicinal trends and the future for folk medicine in Appalachian culture. Three
specific sites are used for a comparative study: Asheville, NC, Clay
County/Perry County, Kentucky and Johnson City, Tennessee.
Shan
Fruehan Sandberg, University of Chicago, 3-2
The Five
Stages of Romance: The Emergence of a Dating Culture Among Young Adults in
Japan
Over the
past decade, anthropologists studying marriage and other forms of romantic
relationships in many different places around the globe have documented a trend
away from an emphasis on social obligation and the reproduction of kinship
systems toward a more ÒcompanionateÓ model of relationships based on notions of
individuality and the concept of romantic love. In Japan, these shifts have
been accompanied by the rise of a Òdating cultureÓ over several decades that
differs in marked ways from more traditional courtship practices. Although some
researchers have argued that such a dating culture has not fully developed in
Japan, drawing on examples from popular culture (such as magazine articles,
self-help books, and television dramas) and my own interviews with unmarried young
women in Tokyo, I document some of the features of this dating culture and
examine young womenÕs understandings of both casual dating and more serious
romantic relationships. I argue that many young people in Japan today
conceptualize their early adulthood as a period of romantic exploration during
which they will form relationships with a series of people. In closing, I
examine some of the implications of this and other changes in premarital
relationships for the Òmarriage postponementÓ (bankonka) and Òmarriage droughtÓ
(kekkon kanbatsu) that have been alarming social critics and policymakers in
Japan.
Shannon
Dosemagen, Univeristy of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, 3-13
Taking the
Global to the Local: Researching Hip Hop in Milwaukee, Wiscosnin
This paper
uses the fieldwork I have conducted as a Master student in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
as a starting point for discussing issues of multi-sitedness, multi-vocality
and the duality of privilege and neglect in my work. Globalization has been
recognized as a powerful force in the shaping of Hip Hop culture, so I instead
discuss issues of multi-sitedness within a localized context between the
elements and ancillary groups of Hip Hop, the duality of segregation and
diversity and the insinuated networks that are inherent to Hip Hop which become
necessary in the ethnography of Hip Hop in Milwaukee. I discuss further issues
of privilege and neglect within the examples of my role as a researcher and
that of graffiti and rap music which explores the use of the term ÒHip HopÓ and
how much of what we consider Hip Hop is now based on public definition.
Sherril R
Miller, Purdue University, 1-7, 2-9
Transformative
Instructional Communication
Transformative Instructional
Communication (TIC) encompasses notions of change and movement from a
management communication style in the classroom to that of a transformative,
more cooperative system of communication that involves a dialogic,
collaborative approach. A rigorous
TIC methodology would enable college/university professors to assist first- and
second-year college students to develop the critical and analytical thinking
skills necessary to succeed in B.A. and B.S. degree programs. In secondary educational settings, TIC
would allow teachers and students to engage, learn, and evolve, in more ways
than the current public high school system permits. In addition to the acquisition of solid academic skills that
would be demonstrated on State-mandated exit examinations, TIC would focus on
helping teachers facilitate the development of personhood in high school
students, a charge educators have been given in many school system under the
guise of character development.
Stacey
Enslow, Purdue University, 1-7
Turtle
Mound: A Creation of Place and Memory
Members and
visitors to an Intentional Community in SE Ohio have developed a reconstruction
of an ancient Native American "animal mound". This paper explores
this process of creation and the emplacement of ideologies and practices that
reinforce memory and identity as intentional, physical acts. I will also
explore how mobile communities create a "home" for identity and
memory in landscapes that are 'borrowed' - as in the case of campers and
festival attendees who use Turtle Mound as a place for scattering ashes of
their beloved dead. These physical and affective acts of semiosis, of memory
emplacement and reconstruction also effect the community whose homes are part
of this landscape, highlighting a discourse between visitors and residents
about 'ownership' of ideological and constructed shared meanings. I will also
look briefly at the role the 'wilderness' in which Turtle Mound was built
contributes to the process of emplacement and affect in community memories and
meanings.
Stephanie
May de Montigny, University of Wisconsin Oshkosh, 2-3
Mark Raymond
Harrington and John Reed Swanton: Defining Indianness in the Southeastern U.S.
Like other
salvage anthropologists, Mark Raymond Harrington and John Reed Swanton
approached Native peoples of the Southeastern United States with the purpose to
document, preserve, and compare practices, beliefs, and objects that
anthropologists thought were on the verge of disappearing. Harrington, in
particular, collected Native objects for George Heye. Through text and
photograph, Harrington and Swanton weighted their portrayals of Native groups
like the Alabama-Coushatta of Texas and the Coushatta of Louisiana towards
elements uncontaminated by European contact. While the resulting depictions
pointed to cultural practices that other authors ignored, they neglected the
complex processes of cultural contact, power, and cultural hybridization that
faced Native peoples at the time. Harrington and Swanton both went beyond the
use of existing written descriptions of Native peoples to visit and talk to
individuals themselves. In that sense, they were among the pioneers of
ethnographic methods. Yet both anthropologists tended to privilege male chiefs
and leaders as representatives of their groups and otherwise typified Native
men and women rather than depicting diverse and complex individuals. The
depictions that Harrington and Swanton created of Native men and women
followed, at least in part, European patriarchal views of gender relations.
Yet, in spite of these limitations, the work of both scholars constituted
methodological innovations and vital contributions to the body of knowledge
concerning Native peoples in the Southeast.
Stephen
Zolvinski, Miami University, 2-14
WhereÕs the
rice? An exploratory investigation of Northern Thai homegardens
Ethnographers
of rural Thai society generally concentrate on irrigated rice as the central
feature of farming systems, while overlooking homegardens that provide useful
products for, and reflect cultural meanings of households. This exploratory
study in a northern Thai hamlet (2001-02) found 10 homegardens to be a rich
source of biodiversity as a total of 185 plants were identified. The uses of
plant products were documented for tangible and non-tangible dimensions of
rural northern Thai culture. The author argues that ethnographers must expand
beyond the cultural meanings of rice agriculture, and as this study shows,
homegarden studies can contribute to a broader understanding of rural Thai
society.
Steven
Maas, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2-9
Rhetorics
of Practice in Bilingual Classrooms in Wales
From the
outside, the two national languages of Wales in Britain-—Welsh and
English—-not only seem to co-exist, but to mingle peacefully. My field
research, however, reveals local tensions as Welshpersons navigate this
multilingual terrain on a daily basis. Teaching at state schools in Wales is
hardly a political activity; yet, politics of language and of territorial
resources both impinge on schooling environments—making primary schools
the hot-point where linguistic, social, and political issues intersect.
Questions about identity that Welshpersons raise in letters to the editor,
pubs, and chapel vestries are not answered or set aside before they can reach
the primary school classroom. Quite to the contrary, these questions take on a new
sort of life when they arrive at classroom, lounge, and assembly hall every
morning. In rural north Wales, where a high-proportion (60-90%) speak Welsh on
a regular basis, teachers wrestle with how to influence pupils and whether they
cross into ÒbrainwashingÓ. This does not stop teachers from using terms like
ÒdrowningÓ for the immersion of children in a Welsh-language environment at
these rural schools. This paper analyzes the rhetorics of practice that help to
construct and sustain categorial frameworks of belonging via 1) the tacit, but
pragmatic communicative choices teachers make during their interactions with
children and 2) larger, school-organizational practices. This provides the
foundation for interpreting the phenomenological sense in which everyday
language practices come to symbolize the substance—life or death—of
minority language communities like those in Wales.
Tabitha
Kukes, University of Northern Iowa, 2-15
Early
Burial Chambers in English Churches: Transition in the cultural meaning of
prestige
Burial
chambers are found within churches throughout England. Found underneath floors
and within altars, they provide an alternate location to churchyards for high
status individuals' burials. This paper analyzes how this trend arose in the
seventh century and changed over the next 400 years. The focus of analysis is
how society conceptualizes status and how this conceptualization is reflected
in burial practices. Key variables are the treatment of decedent remains, the
location of the burials, religion, and the key figures of King Edward the
Confessor and St. Cuthbert.
Teresa
Click, Wichita State University, 2-4
From Behind
the Veil: Negotiating Images in a
Midwestern Town
Without
exaggeration it can be stated that in the Mid-Western States there is a strong
perceived association between Arabic ethnicity and Islam. Within this context,
Arabic and Muslim women are viewed as oppressed, lacking empowerment and
marginalized. Wichita, Kansas is unique because of the numerous venues in which
an individual is able to study the Arabic art of belly dance. Also unique to
this community is the high number of American women studying the art in
relation to the number of Arabic and Muslim women. Although the art form since
its introduction to the United States in 1895 has been highly influenced by the
American film industry and the feminist movement of the 1970's, it is seen as a
symbol of Arabic ethnicity and is viewed positively as a protest against the
perceived oppression of women by Islam. Based on qualitative interviews, I will
explore the reasons why they have chosen to take belly dance classes in a
public setting and how they identify with this particular art form. I argue
that Muslim women who choose to study belly dance are using this as a symbolic
means to negotiate the larger community.
Teresa
Ramos, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 3-11
Managing
Racism, Maintaining Space: A Student Ethnogrpahy of Racism at Illinois
This paper
brings together critical race and women of color feminist theories in order to
investigate issues of cultural citizenship at the University of Illinois
Urbana-Champaign. My research suggests that cultural citizenship hierarchies
are maintained through racial gate-keeping and the development of the
anti-racist racist- a person (or institution like the university)- with
seemingly conflicting racial logics. It does so through an analysis of ÒTacos
and TequilaÓ a racial theme party, hosted by two national Greek Organizations,
that mocked Mexican migrants in stereotypical ways. My preliminary research
reveals that many racial definitions are made meaningful through a corporate
multiculturalism in which diversityÕs benefits are defined by the values of
individualism, privatization, and liability. Examples of these ideologies are
shown in the management of racist actions and the reasons given by the
administration to the campus community for learning about ÒdiversityÓ and
tolerance.
Terri Ann
Liller, Wayne State University, 1-2
Hidden from
View: Locating Aging Lesbians-Methodologies Considerations
Referred to
as the most invisible of an already invisible population, older lesbians have
been ascribed a triple marginalized status relative to age, gender, and sexual
orientation. Methodological considerations arise when conducting ethnographic
studies of older lesbians including recruitment of respondents,
underrepresentation of working-class and minorities, urban versus rural, the
young-old versus those over 65, and the effects living in a heterocentric
society has on oneÕs willingness to participate. Drawing on an anthropological
research study of lesbian caregivers conducted during an upper level
ethnographic methods course this paper echoes these methodological concerns and
expounds on the current state of locating older lesbians. This paper reports on
the methods of sample recruitment, explores ways of accessing this hidden
population, and postulates the discovery of new methodologies as a conduit for
understanding the lived experience of aging lesbians.
Theo
Randall, Indiana University South Bend, 3-1
Religious
Dynamism among the Lelna of Northwestern Nigeria
The paper
examines the religious identity of the Lelna (Dakakari) of northwestern
Nigeria. The Lelna represent a highly religiously diverse ethnic group in that
some adhere to their indigenous (traditional) religious beliefs and practices,
while others are either Christians or Moslems. This religious diversity of the
Lelna conforms to MazruiÕs notion of AfricaÕs Triple Heritage. MazruiÕs Triple
Heritage refers to the existence of traditional African, Islamic, and Western
elements in contemporary African culture. This particular diversity of
religious beliefs and practices of the Lelna occur as a result of both
historical and political factors such as Christian missionary activity in the
late nineteenth century and the presence of Lelna in a region heavily populated
by the predominantly Islamic Hausa. Religious syncretism among the Lelna is
discussed as well.
Thomas H.
Johnson and Helen Johnson, University of Wisconsin - Stevens Point,, 2-9
The Marker
Tree Controversy at Powers Bluff, Wisconsin
Native
occupation of Powers Bluff goes back at least 1,000 years. The hill still has
sacred value to the Ho Chunk, Ojibwa, Menominee, and Potawatomi. Between 1866
and 1936, an inter-tribal refugee community lived on the hill, now a county
park in Central Wisconsin. The community practiced the Drum religion, a
revitalization movement in response to white oppression. They also buried on
the hill, now covered with maples and oak. Oral tradition claims that some of
the trees were purposely deformed to mark graves and trails. This talk will
examine both Native oral tradition and other explanations for the "marker
trees" at Powers Bluff.
Thomas
Walton, University of Minnesota, 3-10
They Don't
Die: Doing Psychiatry in Urban Papua New Guinea
This paper
offers some preliminary observations on the practice of psychiatry in the city
of Port Moresby, the capital of Papua New Guinea. During the late colonial
period, health officials constructed the image of a stress-free native
disoriented to the point of disorder by the processes of modernization and
urbanization. However, in the postcolonial present, a form of triage has
emerged that places psychiatry in a rather marginal position. Here I examine some
of the arguments embedded in contemporary psychiatric discourse that recuperate
the concept of stress in order to reframe understandings of mental illness as a
problem. My initial findings suggest that the viability of psychiatric
knowledge depends on the way in which it defines itself in relation to
infectious disease and the potential for it to address anxieties about
development and productive citizenship.
Tzu-kai
Liu, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2-2
Encountering
Political Authority: Wa Buddhists' Expressions of Respect and
"Nested" Social Hierarchy
This paper
explores the honorific speech and social greetings in an encountering context
where ordinary Wa Buddhists meet significant Han Chinese political authorities
in the borderlands of China and Myanmar. The production and reception of the
conventional Wa honorific speech provide a prism through which we can view the
formation of Wa Buddhists' heightened awareness of relative positionalities
under uneven power dynamics between the cultural and the political on China's
southwest borders. Meanwhile, this speech genre involves not only public
oratory and the moral values of respect and politeness, but also a performative
representation of "nested" social hierarchy. Through selective and
appropriate uses of pronouns and honorific emblems in the performance, the
status of significant Han Chinese officials is marked, and their embodied state
power is recognized through cultural expressions of respect. Studying such an
encountering context helps account for the specific ways in which social
hierarchies and Chinese state power are enacted, imagined, and negotiated.
Vincent G.
Jessen, Loyola University Chicago, 3-10
Baybayin
Baybayin is
the ancient writing system of the Philippines that dates back to the 16th
century. It was widely used throughout the Philippines to write the many
languages found on its islands. My research discusses how the writing system
originated from other islands located near the Philippines and how it has been
used, discontinued, and revived. I discuss the Spanish colonizers and their
experience with the writing system and how they used and modified it. In this
paper I also discuss the topic of ideology and how it can affect the use of a
writing system and lead to its discontinuation. It also discusses how a writing
system can be revived over time to become a symbol of culture or even as an
ethnic identity. The goal of this paper is to provide information to those
unfamiliar with baybayin and create an awareness of the Philippines rich
cultural background before Spanish colonization.
Wendy Marie
Finley, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1-4
When
"Evidence" Isn't Enough
In 1987,
Tawana Brawley, a fifteen year old black woman, accused six white men of
kidnapping and raping her for four days. The case was reminiscent of
interracial sexual violence against black women in American spanning as far
back as slavery. What followed was a whirlwind of media coverage and a grand
jury conclusion that Brawley lied. This paper is not about whether Brawley
lied, but instead, is an examination of the role of evidence in the numerous
publications about the case. I will evaluate the grand jury report, newspaper
articles and legal articles to propounds that this case, which started out as a
teenage girlÕs alleged rape, quickly became a political discourse. By indexing
a preexisting grand narrative of sexual violence against women of color, the
Brawley camp used historical context as their evidence. The anti-Brawley camp
garnered a different kind of evidence to support the idea that black women are
"un-rapeable," which led to their conclusion that BrawleyÕs charges
were a Òhoax".
Whitney
Neugebauer, Eckerd College, 3-12
Geochemical
Signatures at Recently Abandoned House Site in the Puuc Region of Yucatan,
Mexico
Recent
ethnoarchaeological research in Mesoamerica has proposed a link between rural
household behaviors and chemical signatures in the soil. This study explores
that relationship at a recently abandoned house site in the Puuc region of
Yucatan, Mexico. Interviews with local Yucatec Maya speakers who occupied the
site in the 1970s-1980s permit a reconstruction of domestic activities
associated with dormitory and kitchen structures. A soils analysis examines the
degree to which certain measures, specifically those pertaining to phosphorus
and pH, reflect these activities. The evidence suggests that food preparation
and consumption areas are not only chemically identifiable in a
post-abandonment context but can be distinguished from one another based on
separate soil chemistry applications.
William
Eastwood, Indiana University, 3-1
Toward a
New Belonging: Georgian Baptist Negotiations of Orthodox Power
This paper,
based on my dissertation fieldwork in Tbilisi, Georgia in 2007, concentrates on
recent church reforms within the largest association of Baptist churches in
Georgia, the Evangelical-Baptist Church of Georgia [EBC]. Specifically, I focus
on the specific ritual performances and symbolic practices that have followed
the EBCÕs reform-inspired adoption of several Orthodox traditions, including
iconography, the wearing of priestly vestments, and the introduction of a
Sunday liturgy, among others. Such changes to Baptist practice attempt to
negotiate the dominant power of Georgian Orthodox Christianity, which has for
decades assumed a key symbolic role in national politics. In the wake of
national independence in 1991 and the increased sensitivity to religious
identification in those years, Baptists and other religious minorities faced growing
marginalization. Negotiating local power, however, has put the EBC at odds with
its own Baptist legacy and Baptist discourses about appropriate worship, which
are themselves antagonistic to Orthodox Tradition. By analyzing ritual
transformations within the EBC as a tug-of-war between Baptist and Orthodox
discourses about appropriate worship, I conclude that instead of a wholesale
conversion to Orthodoxy, Georgian Baptists are creating an amalgam of Orthodox
symbols and rituals with Baptist sensibilities. What emerge are practices and
performances that embody new meanings of national belonging that compete with
(hegemonic) cultural expectations of Orthodox practice even while remaining
free from the current national ideology that has commandeered Orthodox
Christianity in building the Georgian nation-state.
Willie
McKether, The University of Toledo, 2-5
From
Narrative to Network Data: Collecting and Converting
This
presentation describes the process of discovery used to convert interview data
into a format readable into Multinet for social network analysis. The author
describes the steps used to collect and store interview data in Microsoft Word,
the preparation process for exporting the interviews to Atlas.ti for coding,
the coding process, and the conversion path that allowed him to export the
coded qualitative data from Atlas.ti to SPSS and ultimately to MultiNet for
social network analysis. In addition to the network maps generated from
narrative interviews, an important methodological outcome of the five-step
process is that thematic as well as social network coded data are created in a
single file, thus allowing researchers to examine networks in the context
discussed by interviewees. This presentation is significant because it
describes a replicable conversion technique that can be used by experienced
scholars and those unfamiliar with the range of network analysis programs and
conversion possibilities.
Xiao-bo
Yuan, University of Chicago, 3-1
Miracles in
the Everyday: Narratives of Crisis and Intervention in post-Katrina Mississippi
ÒHurricane
Katrina was not an act of God; the act of God is what we are doing
nowÓ—this was a statement made by a Presbyterian hurricane-relief
organizer in Mississippi one year after the devastating hurricane. My paper, drawing
on fieldwork conducted in Gulfport-Biloxi in 2006, examines the claims of that
statement, and addresses the theorizations of causality, authority, and
legitimacy in the discourse of Christian groups working on post-Katrina
reconstruction. Focusing on several organizations operating in Mississippi, I
explore the ways in which Christian volunteers imagined their own roles in
these spaces of crisis. I suggest that the proliferation of miraculous
narratives in the everyday activity of Christian groups points toward a
significant enterprise in the Christian community — that is, the
production and exchange of stories that bridge the gap between Biblical text
and this-worldly experience. By scrutinizing the construction of narratives of
crisis and intervention, my aim is to highlight the unique logics employed by
faith-based organizations in authorizing their work to not only reconstruct but
reshape communities. I also wish to place these conceptions in the larger
context of post-Katrina questions about the limits of state power and the role
of religious actors in the public sphere.
Yuen-ki
LAI, Purdue University, 3-2
Masculine
Lesbians in Hong Kong: Negotiation between Tomboys and TomboyÕs Girls
TB/TBG
role-play is common among lesbian couples in Hong Kong. ÒTBÓ, an abbreviation
for tomboy, is the one who plays a masculine role; ÒTBGÓ, an abbreviation for
tomboyÕs girl, plays a feminine role. If ÒtomboyÓ does not exist, the concept
of ÒtomboyÕs girlÓ cannot be formed. Literally, this implies the subordinate position
of tomboyÕs girls. However, it is just a superficial interpretation. My
experience argues that lesbian masculinities are not solely constructed by
masculine lesbians, the TBs; instead their counterparts, the TBGs, play an
important role in defining and constructing the content and the representation
of lesbian masculinities. I argue that TBsÕ masculinities are not static but
open to negotiation. TBs and TBGs both contribute to the construction of
lesbian masculinities.